Even big Corporations have a hard time getting good feedback;
Their good customers are prejudiced FOR them and are bad sources of perspective, and,
Their NON customers don't give a darn.
If someone sees your house, and they hate the colors, or the openness of the kitchen area; they are not going to say anything, they don't care and it doesn't benefit them. What are you going to do, change it for them and invite them back?
Then, you have their Agent running interference; the majority of Agents will not pass on feedback; they are concerned with their own problems, particularly, the Clients who just saw a house that they do not want to buy!
Your best source of feedback is a Broker's Open House; have you done one?
Set it up right with drinks and snacks so that they will hang around and talk.
Also, invite your neighbors in, people who are not interested in buying your house:
And when they talk, LISTEN, don't be sensative that they are criticizing your tastes; you should be decorating for the BUYERS, not yourself.
Good luck and may God bless
To answer this question...........it shouldn't.
After reading your question here, and on the other thread, it is apparent that you're frustrated ..and really need to have a nice long chat with your agent.
You shouldn't have to be asking strangers about feedback and price reductions and what to do to get your house sold.
You selected an agent..........hopefully for all the right reasons. Make use of his or her expertise and knowledge of the local market.
Make a list of questions, sit down and have a conversation......ask for a record of showings... and yes, feedback, too.
If you keep hearing the buyers thought the price was too high - that's important for you to know.....if a part of the house (decor, colors, etc) doesn't work in some way for buyers, and you can do something to correct it...that's important to know.
Any input may shed some light in your situation.
You also need to be kept in the loop as to what is happening in your market.....does your agent tell you of new listings? recently closed and under contract listings?
I'd be frustrated, too, if I were kept in the dark.
And, look. I'm just trying to help here. You're not going to get what you want. Buyers don't always express why they're rejecting a house, and agents aren't going to interrogate them on it. When I show a house, and they say, "next," we move on. I don't ask them, "What should the Seller do to make the property more appealing to you," we move on.
Your friends and neighbors are likely to agree with you and also not be a reliable source of feedback. However, I do think that your agent could set up a system for checking in on showings and repeat visits. Here in Seattle, we can get automated keybox reports, I don't know what to do in Gilbertsville but maybe a sign asking agents to leave a business card, or a note on the listing to call the agent before showing.
All the best,
Licensed Associate Broker
Accredited Buyer Representative
William Raveis Legends Realty Group
A few other quick thoughts, some of which are mentioned below:
Lots of people (buyers and agents) don't like to give negative feedback. They just feel it's impolite. That's why some don't provide feedback. Or why you see sellers saying: "All my feedback is positive. And yet my house isn't selling." When they've said that and there have been pictures online, I've taken a look. Usually, the house looks dreadful. So the feedback might be: "Nice, large living room." Not: "Smells like a zoo. Dark and dingy, too."
Most sellers and many listing agents get defensive at negative feedback. You see that more in person, such as at a broker's open. Still . . . I've walked into terribly overcluttered homes and when the listing agent has asked: "So, what do you think?" I've responded, "Well, it probably would look better if some of this stuff were cleared out." The response has been: "We've done a lot already." Or at a recent rehab, while a lot of work had been done, the deck--stained and splintery--hadn't been touched. "Well, what do you think?" I commented that the house would show a lot better if the deck had been replaced, or at least cleaned and stained." The response: "Well, the investor only had so much money." Duh! You asked; I answered.
Along a similar line, some problems are obvious--for example, tiny bedrooms. There's nothing that can be done about them, and likely the listing agent is already aware of the problem. So many agents figure there's no point in saying, "Those bedrooms are tiny," only to have the listing agent respond, "Yes, they are a bit on the cozy side."
Also, some agents--as they see it--don't like doing the job of the listing agent. Their reaction: "It's the listing agent's job to get this place in decent condition. If he/she needs assistance, hire a stager. It's not my job to help you sell your listing."
And some agents figure that the only feedback that's appropriate is if a buyer makes an offer. No offer means: "The house wasn't suitable."
One suggestion: Often at broker's opens, agents are incentivized with gift cards--such as a $10 card for Starbucks. Or a gas card. You can do the same for any agent who shows your property and provides feedback. Or offer a card a week, given randomly to one agent who provides feedback. With an investment of $50-$100, you ought to be able to get some helpful responses.
Hope that helps.
Mainly because agents are so busy...at least in my area. Often when I work with buyers I see 6-8 houses a day and by the time an agent calls me 4 days later for feedback, I don't remember the house they are talking about. Also...the listing agent should know the defaults already. Is it priced too high? on a busy street? painted orange...so when we get voicemails, these are the last calls of the day we return.
It's just a matter of time. The best feedback I can give is if we want to write an offer.
In other words, we as the clients, have the right to request stats! That is actually part of a realtor's job, right? As Ms. Debbie Livingston and our Chicagoland realtor Jan McNulty both confirmed...Realtors need to provide feedback in various forms to their clients.
Look out Western Kentucky realtors...It's time you actually begin "playing the game" the right way for your 6%!
I know it is stressful to have a house on the market, but as Don and Ron point out, feedback is rarely candid and honest, and for the most part, who cares what people who don't like the house think?
Back in the old days, we'd get fifty, sixty people at an open house, but we'd get two or five offers. Now, according to the Feedback Rules theory, we'd want to know why fifty people rejected the house. But we didn't care, because someone wanted to buy it.
Point being - if people don't want to buy it, it doesn't really matter why. You're not going to add a bedroom, lower the cathedral ceiling, point the kitchen toward the east, turn a Colonial into a Contemporary. And I've found that people who keep a dirty smelly house aren't going to clean it just because of "feedback."
Well to tell you the truth, buyer agents are usually driving around with numerous buyers during the course of the day, and might not get back to the listing agent without a little "prompting" from them. It would be best for the listing agent to make calls at the end of the day..or next day and request any feedback from the buyer agents.