I used to live in those neck of the woods when I was a young married (off Broadway and 59th). My favorite babysitter lived off 62th St past Fruitridge. Tahoe Park was a popular choice for first time homebuyers even then. I have pictures of my newborn twins at Tahoe Park.
A quick look of solds does show the immediate area anywhere from $58,000-$95,000 which makes me want to send out an email to all my first time homebuyers because it is such a cute area and has such
a great commute and close to everything. But...
good news is that the pendings are going from the low 100's to a home that went pending sale in 49 days on Tahoe Way listed at $299,000 - which suggests it won't be "too" far off the list price. It was a 2 bed 1 bath 1203 sq feet.
Without drawing a specific map search for you, which wouldn't take into account square footage, btw, I can tell you that 95820 has an average listed price of $119,000 for April. It's been steadily increasing ever since December. The average sold is $81,000, down from $84,000 in March.
The average price PSF for 95820 is $71.