Glad you're happy with your agent.
I see you're from Clinton. I'm originally from Madison, and I know that where my family's current house is the pricing is triple what it would be for a similarly sized home in a neighborhood a few blocks away. Clinton has a very diverse home market especially when you compare the waterfront neighborhoods and their surrounding streets with homes in north of the Post Road.
Also, at the end of the day the key part of your comment is "priced higher." It's the reason good real estate agents don't use "active" prices in their market analysis. I can price a garage at $1,000,000 but that doesn't mean it should sell at that.
I hope you find a buyer!