Home Selling in 21784>Question Details

Michael, Home Seller in

Should I consider renting a home I own if I will only break even on the rental price versus mortgage?

Asked by Michael, Thu Sep 27, 2007

Help the community by answering this question:


It does depend on a lot of variables, what your financial situation is currently (can you afford to rent out), what your personality is like (can you deal with your tenants), what time do you have (do you have the time to fix anything that needs to be fixed), do you have a knowledgable real estate agent, can you afford to hire a property management company?

Investing is a great idea for those who have the time and the ability. Investing in Real Estate is not for everyone.

The best answer is: it all depends. Michael, your best bet is to sit down with an agent and a tax advisor and figure out whats best for you.
0 votes Thank Flag Link Sat Oct 6, 2007
One point of clarification regarding Mansur's answer, he mentions that: "If the home qualified as a primary residence renting it for two years will remove this tax advantage."

This is what the IRS (check reference below) says: "To exclude gain, a taxpayer must both own and use the home as a principal residence for two of the five years before the sale. The ownership and use periods need not be concurrent. The two years may consist of 24 full months or 730 days. Short absences, such as for a summer vacation, count as periods of use, but longer breaks, such as a one-year sabbatical, do not. The taxpayer also must not have excluded gain on another home sold during the two years before the current sale."

As always, check with a knowledgeable tax professional that specializes in real estate.
0 votes Thank Flag Link Fri Sep 28, 2007
This question has many variable. Mansur spelled them out very well. It really depends on your financial stablility in regards to the property in question. Are you moving out of the area? If so you will need to interview a couple of property management companies and get their opinion. I would also speak with a CPA to get the tax advantages and disadvantages. Know what to expect. Whatever you decide to do, you want to be well informed so there won't be any unpleasant surprises down the road. Good luck!
Web Reference: http://carriecrowell.com
0 votes Thank Flag Link Fri Sep 28, 2007
Probably if your market is down like most of the US, but it is probably better to hire a management company to find you a GOOD TENANT! They are hard to find, and a bad one can do much damage to your property, we just had one that did over $10,000 of damages, plus not paying rent for 3 months - I voted against renting to the client in the beginning, but the owner overruled me - now they tell me I was right, but they are about $ 13,000 in the hole!
Also remember, lots of tax advantages to renting - you can depreciate the home, which adds to the bottom line - the depreciation (I believe 26.5 years straight line) is deducted dollar for dollar from any taxes you owe - lets say your home has a value of $400K, with the land as 25% of the value your yearly deductiion for depreciation will be $11,321 per year, or almost a grand a month - thats why investors are always talking about after tax dollars - if you are in a 35% bracket thats $ 330.00 per month added to your income in real dollars. If you have more questions, call a good tax advisor - we Realtors just dabble in tax advantages - hope you do well!!
Web Reference: http://www.billwootan.com
0 votes Thank Flag Link Thu Sep 27, 2007
You've received some great responses.
I recommend "The Millionaire Real Estate Investor" by Garry Keller, Dave Jenks, and Jay Papason.
Excellent primer! chris@thehellerteam.com More information on the website
0 votes Thank Flag Link Thu Sep 27, 2007
Keith Sorem, Real Estate Pro in Glendale, CA
Hello Michael,
As a Realtor, a past property manager, and a current lord, I can relate to your situation.
You should take into account what your local market is like. Here in Illinois, we are currently in a buyer's market. Sellers are taking a loss because our most of our market is saturated with homes. If you haven’t had a complimentary CMA done on your home, you should consult a real estate agent to see what price range your home would be in, and have them look at excess in inventory, or need for your type of home.
You should also have your agent look up past market trends in your area. Holding on to your home, renting it at a break even price, and taking any tax deductions, if applicable, could be worthwhile if your home area tends appreciate.
Most important is taking a look at your financial situation. Is the home paid off? Can you afford to, and are you willing to, hold on to it until it is paid off so that your only expenses insurance, property taxes and maintenance?
My advice is to take a look at your personal situation, consult a tax professional and a real estate professional. Feel free to contact me if you would like more information. 217-979-1805 or RosaDavisson@Remax.net
Best wishes to you, Rosa Davisson
0 votes Thank Flag Link Thu Sep 27, 2007
You might want to look into getting a loan with different payment options. I know Wachovia has a pick a pay loan where you have 4 different payment options every month. Might be a good way to stay afloat untill prices go back up and you can sell.
0 votes Thank Flag Link Thu Sep 27, 2007
Hi Michael:

Mansur is right on.

Here is an in-depth "Smart Money" article on the pros and cons of renting v. selling. This should answer basically any question you have and help you make a decision. http://www.smartmoney.com/home/selling/index.cfm?story=rentorsell

Best of luck!
0 votes Thank Flag Link Thu Sep 27, 2007
It really depends on the rest of your financial situation. There are more things to consider besides whether you will break even. Like how much time and effort it will take to find a GOOD (emphasis on good) tenant that will pay on time. Will you be managing the property yourself? If this is your first time renting to someone, I really recommend having a property management company. I've had rental property since 1998 and am sure I would have gotten rid of the property if I had to manage it myself. There are countless frustrations that you will not have to deal with directly if you have a property management company managing the property. You will not have to hear sob stories from tenants about why they can't pay their rent on time, for example. (Believe me, I've heard it before.) It also gives you a level of protection from lawsuits. Obviously, we all have biases, but in landlording, you really cannot. You must accept the first qualified person. Or else you are a great candidate for a lawsuit.

Also you must also consider the actual costs of maintaining a rental property. (One way to do this is to look at the maintenance expenses you had in the past year in the house to get a rough idea.) Are you considering those when you mention that you will only break even?

There are many other tax-related factors (that you should speak to a tax professional about) that you should consider also like depreciation and additional tax deductible costs. If you are a high income individual the benefits of these alone could make it worth owning a rental property even if you have negative cash flow. And if you qualify as a real estate professional, there are even more benefits. Make sure you consult with a tax professional. (Ensure that you hire one that really understands real estate.)

Also, regarding costs of owning a rental property, as you can already imagine, it is worth the money to hire a good CPA, if you don't already have one.

Hope this helps!

Let us know if you have more specific questions.
Web Reference: http://www.creiZ.com
0 votes Thank Flag Link Thu Sep 27, 2007
Hi Michael. You really should consult with a tax professional because the answer to your question depends on your overall financial situation. There are lots of factors to consider. Sorry I can't be of more help.
Web Reference: http://www.go2kw.com
0 votes Thank Flag Link Thu Sep 27, 2007
Ute Ferdig -…, Real Estate Pro in New Castle, DE
Search Advice
Ask our community a question
Email me when…

Learn more

Copyright © 2016 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |  
Have a question? Visit our Help Center to find the answer