Possible to sell 2 year old condo for more than brand new condo, built very similar?

Ashley Merritt
Both Buyer and Seller
Knoxville, TN

Currently live in a 2 year old condo. I bought as new construction for 98k. Added a large fenced yard, hardwoods, more open floor plan....
There are brand new condos, built by the same builder within a few blocks from me listed for 104k-107k...there can be add ons...
We're wanting to sell my condo for 115k-125k...does that seem impossible with brand new condos listed for less? Also, neighbors have condo listed for 109k and 114k right now.
My realtor will run a comp, I'm sure...just seeing what the opinions are.
Zip is 37912...In the Inskip/Fountain City area of Knoxville.

Answers (5)
Best answer: Dave DeVos
First to answer: Tom McGuirk,…
Jim Lee
Agent
Knoxville, TN

Historically it's tough to compete with new construction versus a resale.

Further what you want to sell your condo for is irreverent. Buyers decide what they're willing to pay for a new home and you can either sell it to them for that price or try to negotiate a compromise.

Given the Knoxville market today it does not seem realistic to me to expect to sell a condo you bought 2 years ago for 98K and get $115,000 or more 2 years later.

You might want to take a look at some of my blog postings where I've graphed the Knox County closed real estate transactions for this year.

Mon Jun 1 2009, 07:17
Dave DeVos
Agent
Crossville, TN
BEST ANSWER

Your problem is very common in this market. You must create an answer as to why some one would pay more for your condo - location, improvements, size, garage, etc. In your comps concentrate on closing prices not listing prices..
$115k-125k may be unrealistic considering your neighbors listings. According to the Knoxville Area Association of Realtors there are 25 condos listed in Fountain City priced between $90-125 k; 30 have been sold this year
Avg Closing price $103,517 Days on the market ave 79 Ave listing price$105,237
Let your Realtor advise you. Good luck! DAVE

Mon Nov 24 2008, 06:40
Sherry Wheeler
Agent
Knoxville, TN

Hi Ashley,

Luckily you're in a price point that is selling well here. I'm sure you know the comps will dictate your listing price. There is a lot of smart people out there buying right now. If you are planning on moving up you're smart to be wanting to do so. Without knowing where your condo is I can't give any advice. Do you feel like you paid too much 2 years ago? This is the problem most people are facing with todays pricing.

Sun Nov 23 2008, 07:12
Tom Stevens, Mo...
Agent
Eagle Nationwide Mor...

Anything's possible, but this sounds improbable.

Agreed - your best bet is have a comparable market analysis done by a real estate agent.

From a lender's perspective, your buyers may have trouble unless they have some spare cash. Unless an appraisal shows your home is worth more for newer comparable sales as their down payment and financing would be based on the lesser of the appraised value or sale price. Thus overpricing can hurt even if there are immediate offers.

A new fence is nice and adds desirability but adds nothing to the structure. Upgrading the floor plan won't net you 100% return on investment. My guess is that you would have to hold onto your home a bit longer to get the price you want.

If you have any questions about financing anywhere in these United States, please let me know!

Tom

Tom Stevens, Eagle Nationwide Mortgage Co., a subsidiary of Eagle National Bank
Thomas.Stevens@ENMCdirect.com
508-653-2223 x 25

Sat Nov 22 2008, 22:43
Tom McGuirk, Br...
Agent
Hampton, NH
FIRST ANSWER

Not being an expert in your market, I can only comment on how this scenerio would play out in market. If you purchased a condo new construction AND the complex still has new construction available, then potential BUYERS would prefer the newly constructed units over you unit. If, as you said, the new construction condos are in a different neighborhood, your condo may be worth more IF you neighborhood is preferable to the other nighborhood.

My advice, TRUST whatever your REALTOR has to say regarding price and marketing (as long as they are qualified and experienced.) They are the experts in your market.

Sat Nov 22 2008, 22:18

Didn’t find what you were looking for? Ask a question!

More Q&A about Home Selling in 37912

View all »
How to utilize extra bedroom's space when selling?
Answered Sat Sep 19 2009, 11:33 by Michele Webb in 37912
Read all 7 answers
Replace vinyl flooring with Tile to sale?
Answered Tue Nov 25 2008, 06:23 by Tina Evans in 37912
Read all 13 answers
Search Advice

Ask a question

Got a real estate question? Get answers from locals, experts and real estate pros.
Ask
Email me when…

Learn more

View all » 1 - 3 of 216
Copyright © 2009 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Help us improve our service—send us feedback