If the property is on the MLS the listing agent is obligated to post the sale price within 2 days of the closing on the MLS site. The tax record is more accurate in price but could take longer to be viewed on line.
The Local MLS, GSMLS.com for Nutley is the best place to find sold info
Contact me for a free no obligation home evaluation
Unwavering Commitment to Service, Unsurpassed Results