BEST ANSWER
Robin, that is a great question. One thing to remember is that some of the time, a price a short sale is listed for has not come from the bank - in fact, the bank may not have had any input on price. I have seen short sales where the agent was clearly just trying to stimulate activity, and the price could not be supported by a BPO (broker price opinion), which is what a bank will require as part of their approval process. Recently, there was one that started out at about $450k, and once the bank got involved, it was re-listed at over $600k - more in line with the market in that area.
My anecdotal experience is that much of the time, an REO is marketed at a lower price than the home has been listed for as a short sale. That may have as much to do with time on the market and declining values as anything. There also appear to be some write-offs that the banks can take once it's theirs that improve their ability to take a lower price.
A bank-owned property has many advantages for the buyer, not the least of which is that the bank is more motivated and more willing to negotiate meaningful concessions at that point than when it is a short sale. They also become interested in getting the deal done, which is not always the case with short sales. After about 10-14 days on the market, banks usually pursue price reductions until the offers come rolling in.
Hope my input is helpful!
Thu Oct 2 2008, 21:47