What will it take for sellers to realize that their homes won't appraise vs new construction prices?

Rob
Home Buyer
Shelton, CT

new construction ranges from $190 to $210 in Shelton , Monroe , Newtown Areas.People with used homes are often asking over these amounts and banks will not lend because you can't comp a new home vs used.The guidlines are vey tight right now on this subject when it comes to appraisal time.

Answers (4)
Best answer: Sean Dawes
First to answer: Amanda A. Al…
Frank A. Hoinsky
Broker
Ansonia, CT

I expect you are referring to sq ft cost at $190 to $210.
YOu can only make an educated decision when you personally see the homes in your price range. There are plenty of them and you won't be disappointed.
Frank Hoinsky, Broker
Ansonia,CT

Mon Nov 2 2009, 05:17
J R
Agent
New York, NY

First of all, I will not list an overpriced house, so appriasals haven't been an issue for me. The rare times I've had one that was slightly over, I never got close to selling it without a major price cut in negotiations. I didn't get showings!

Let me know when you have an answer, I am currently dealing with this issue with a potential new listing. This acquaintance thinks their home is worth $100,000 more than new construction 1/4 mile away. I hate to walk away from an acquaintance but I've done it before. One I walked away from a year and a half ago is still listed with an ineffective agent who is in my own office. The seller has missed the boat. I feel bad for them but they chose to list with someone who lied to them. Go figure.

Sun Nov 1 2009, 07:19
Sean Dawes
Agent
Philadelphia, PA
BEST ANSWER

Tell the seller to get their home appraised. Then when it comes in less than what they think, remind them no one will buy the home since the bank wont lend. Only way is if you get a cash buyer who doesnt know a thing about market pricing.

I would include comps of similar homes with your offer. See if that helps.



Sean Dawes

Sun Nov 1 2009, 06:35
FIRST ANSWER

My suggestion is to put in your offer with the wording that House must appraise at full purchase price. That way you are covered in case the house does not appraise.

Often times homes have been updated to be much better than new and that could be why the prices seem too high for you, but they will definately appraise out. There are many factors involved in the appraisal process, not just new vs old.

Hope this helps....AManda

Sun Nov 1 2009, 05:33

Didn’t find what you were looking for? Ask a question!

Search Advice

Ask a question

Got a real estate question? Get answers from locals, experts and real estate pros.
Ask
Email me when…

Learn more

View all » 1 - 3 of 7
Copyright © 2009 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Help us improve our service—send us feedback