As a 21 year resident of Natick and the father of three teenagers with two at Natick High School (new school) and one just gratuated, I might be somewhat partial to Lilja where they all attended. They went on to Wilson Middle School then to the High School.
My honest answer is that that both elementary schools have rated well with all of our friends.
As an Realtor and Architect in Natick and a member of many Natick Boards and Associations, I can help you find the right house in the right neighborhood.
Feel free to call me at 508-864-2878 or E-Mail at firstname.lastname@example.org
Aaron Socrat, Relator & Architect
Good luck in your home search!
I have worked as both a buyer and seller agent in Natick a good amount. I also have clients with kids in the school system I can put you in touch with. feel free to shoot me an email or call.