BEST ANSWER
Hello Peter and thanks for your email and post.
I've read most of your comments in the past two weeks and I agree with you that the economy is shedding jobs, however, this is just one component of the overall economic picture--and while significant--it is not the only component of the economy. Further, as most economists are noting today, while the number of layoffs continue, the amount of national job retraction is less than anticipated AND has been steadily declining in the past months. I also like to point out that the jobs figures now are based on 'raw data' and don't really shape up for about 90 days, so it will be interesting to see how the numbers are modified in the near future. Couple this "lessening of the worsening" (so to speak) with an retail economy that has actually grown 7 percent in the past quarter, a recovery in the stock markets, financial markets, and spending in the private sector, and I'm prepared to say that we just might be past the "bottom".
Does this mean that its still a bad time to buy homes or that housing prices will continue to fall dramatically, as you have suggested in other posts? I am prepared to say no. Despite the worsening jobs news, we are seeing a lot more activity on homes available in Santa Clara now. Appropriately priced, attractive homes are selling and obtaining multiple offers. My counterparts in our company in San Mateo County and San Francisco are also reporting similar spikes of welcome activity. The DOMs (days on market) numbers are also dropping, so, at least for now, things are looking a bit better than I think any of us had anticipated.
The point most Realtors are making now is that, if this not the "bottom" of the market, it is pretty darned close, and waiting until you hit a rock bottom or taking the strategy of buying on the upswing may cause you to lose the chance to purchase a suitable home at an affordable price. As an example, I sold my home in San Jose in June 2008 (yes, the price fell from its high in February 2008 but I could see the market falling so I sold), and bought in October 2008 in the Cupertino Middle School/Homestead High School area of Sunnyvale near Los Altos. While home prices continued to fall in Sunnyvale in November and December, I was comfortable that I had purchased a home for less than it had sold for in the past year. Today, surrounding homes in my neighborhood are UP $100,000 from my purchase price in October, 2008, so I am ahead in a down economy. Admittedly, this is not possible in all areas, but the vast majority of homeowners who purchased in Santa Clara in October, November and December, a large majority are seeing their investments show a small profit as of this spring.
So, in essence, I agree with you that the jobs are being lost, but I respectfully disagree that the current losses are significant enough to further erode the housing market here. There are too many other factors currently in play (such as lowered housing prices, credit, loans, interest rates) that are offsetting the other negative factors created by job losses. I also don't think that you'll see as many homes on the market this year as in the past, so inventory may not increase dramatically as it has in the past years at this time.
Of course, as I've said before, I can be wrong--there are too many other issues at play and far too much investor emotion in the market for me to say, with concrete assuredness that what I'm seeing (some market recovery) will accelerate anytime soon. Let's just say I'm "bullish" on the economy for the remainder of the year, and if I'm wrong, well, I'm going to owe a lot of people lunch.... : )
Thanks again for your post. This is just my two cents on the issue of the economy and I appreciate and value your input on this and other posts.
Sincerely,
Grace Morioka, SRES, e-Pro
Area Pro Realty
Tue Apr 14 2009, 10:33