My boyfriend and I are in the process of purchsing a condo in Brooklyn, NY.

Cindy
Home Buyer
Astoria, Queens, NY

We are purchasing a condo in a new development with 16 units. When we first signed the agreement we were told we might close in July but that there may be some delays. We were understanding but October is almost over and the building has been completed. We are now being told that we won't be able to close until they sell 90% of the units (4 of the remaining 5). My boyfriend and I are worried because this could take a year. We are in an economic crunch, buyers don't usually purchase during the winter and we believe the developer is asking too much for the remaining units, particularly the two studios and the remaining 1 bedroom. We have been able to extend our current lease until the end of November. However, our landlord has told us that we will have to sign a 1yr lease if we wish to stay in our current apartment in Astoria, Queens. Do we have any recourse?

Answers (6)
Emilio Velazquez
Broker
10002

My dear purchaser's get your self a real estate attorney.

Wed Jun 24 2009, 15:54
shong
Agent
New York, NY

As others have said, it is very unusual that you can not close until 90% of the building is sold. And this is the sponsor telling you this? Or your mortgage broker? In 99.99% of the new developments, the sponsor wants to close even more than the buyers. They usually have a debt they have to pay for the construction. If this is something that your mortgage told you, then youre dealing with the wrong person. sunny_hong@countrywide.om

Sun Oct 26 2008, 18:52
Jenet Levy
Agent
New York, NY

Hi, Cindy,

Unfortunately delays are the norm when purchasing new construction. The dates developers and their sales team tell buyers are always very optimistic. Who is telling you 90% have to sell in order to close? Is it your bank? That is extremely unusual if so. The building ought to be able to get the TCO (temporary certificate of occupancy) when the building is mostly finished. That's all they need to start closings. Ask your attorney about this 90% thing. Also, talk with your attorney and have him/her see if there is a "right to rescind" in the contract. That means there might be a clause that if the developer is not ready to close by a certain date you have the right to pull out and get your deposit back. I represent buyers and sellers in Manhattan and Brooklyn, and in a Brooklyn new development where I provided the buyer to the sale of one unit, I was able to leverage the right to rescind to negotiate a price reduction. In other words, I told the developer that since they were beyond the the date stated in the right to rescind, my buyers were going to exercise that right and walk, but that if the developer wanted to save the deal we would require a price reduction, particularly because the other units have already been reduced, and it wasn't fair for my people to both pay the original price and have the long waiting time. We got the reduction.
On the lease issue, I would suggest you talk to the landlord and explain the situation. You will probably have to sign a new lease, but landlords are generally fine with you breaking the lease because the vacancy rate is low and they can replace you with a higher price for the next renter.

Sun Oct 26 2008, 17:06
Scott Godzyk
Agent
New Hampshire

Why would they require 90% of the units be sold? is this a requirement from your mortgage company or from the town where it is located? if you want an out or advise, first check with your agent to see hwat they advise otherwise seek out a real estate attorney who can review your contract and help you wither get things moving or get out of the contract. good luck

Fri Oct 24 2008, 07:22
Jolie MussNYC/M...
Broker
Upper West Side, New...

Cindy,
I hope you retained a competent NY Real Estate attorney before you signed your agreement.
Non- performance penalties for not closing or moving out by a certain date have been written into contracts by my attorneys, for homes I have personally purchased in the past, though they were not new construction...
Has anyone closed or moved into the new building yet? Buyers purchase anytime of the year and just before year's end is very popular for various reasons. What does your lawyer say? If you would like to speak about this with another NY real estate attorney, please email me and I will send you a list..

Web Reference: http://joliemuss.com
Fri Oct 24 2008, 07:20
FIRST ANSWER

Have your lawyer review your contract for timelines that the builder has agreed to. Your recourse, if a timeline passes, is likely limited to being able to cancel and get your deposit back, but have them review it for you and see if there are any loopholes available. Builders often cover delays; recourse is usually very limited. Good luck- your attorney can/should advise.

Web Reference: http://optionsrealty.com
Fri Oct 24 2008, 06:51

Didn’t find what you were looking for? Ask a question!

More Q&A about Home Buying in 10002

View all »
any body could refer a lawyer who knows foreclosure process.?
Answered Wed Sep 10 2008, 11:23 by Laura Rusiecki, As… in 10002
Read all 6 answers
Do you feel the lower east side is a fairly safe investment?
Answered Fri Mar 28 2008, 17:27 by Richard V Hamilton in 10002
Read all 3 answers
Search Advice

Ask a question

Got a real estate question? Get answers from locals, experts and real estate pros.
Ask
Email me when…

Learn more

View all » 1 - 3 of 1,987
Copyright © 2009 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Help us improve our service—send us feedback