Home Buying in 18102>Question Details

Natalie, Home Buyer in Allentown, PA

Issues with homes being appraised correctly through KNBT bank

Asked by Natalie, Allentown, PA Mon Oct 5, 2009

i found a home right across from the firestation at 7th n chew in allentown it is a renovated home by alliance for building communities. the selling price is $110,000 the home came back appraised for that price but yet when i checked the comps on zillow, homes in that neighborhood were only selling for no more than $98,000. i also found a home for the same price at 11th and chew a historic home with the same comparables except that its in a better neighborhood and it has a garage, the house only appraised for $88,000. i was Shocked so were my realtors. tell me how does a home in a worst neighborhood which comps arent as good appraise and the other doesnt? i think something is fishy with my lender KNBT because they work with Alliance for building community all there homes appraise while homes that arent built by hadc or alliance for building communites are not being appraise for nearly enough, is anyone aware of this on going problem in the lehigh valley?

Help the community by answering this question:


Hello Natalie!

Using comps on Zillow is not accurate. Using comps on the Lehigh Valley MLS are very accurate. As the Lehigh Valley MLS is what the appraisers are using. Zilliow only has information on the price, beds and baths etc. It does not have information on what updates have been done or the area that home is located. Pretty much Zilliow is just a computer generated report based on the Lehigh County Data that has been typed in by Lehigh County and the County can be anywhere from 30 to 90 days behind on homes sold. The Lehigh Valley MLS is up to the min accurate. Soon as a home is sold and the sold date is entered into the system...the information is live. Also, the appraisers us homes that are under agreement and available with Contingency..they can tell if a home was sold and settled that was a foreclosure or short sale vs someone who just sold it has a reg seller.

So, If your Real Estate Agents are finding no comps on the MLS for the home you want to purchase to prove the value..THEN this is fishy...but, I have a really good feeling this will not be the case.

I hope this helps you and good luck
2 votes Thank Flag Link Mon Oct 5, 2009
Hi, Natalie!

First of all, Zillow is not a reliable source for comparables. I have seen homes on Zillow that are either under or over market value. The market value of homes are constantly changing. Therefore, a professional real estate agent will be better able to assist you in that sense. The current sold comparables will be used including the location and condition of the homes, which do make a difference. Also, when an agent does a comp, it does not inlcude foreclosures, which can bring down the value considerably.

Banks, in general, can no longer choose the appraisers. They are now computer generated and can be assigned to any appraiser that may be available. Sometimes, the appraiser may not be from the immediate area. They will use comps from the Multiple Listing Service and make adjustments to come up with the appraised value of the home. For example, if a home has a swimming pool and the subject property does not, an adjustment on the comparable home will be made. A value will be subtracted from the comparable property because the subject property does not have a pool.

Hope this helps clear up things for you.

Brigita McKelvie, REALTOR, e-PRO, GRI
Keller Williams Real Estate, Bethlehem, PA
Office: 610-867-8888 Direct: 610-393-9424
E-mail: brigita@brigitamklv.com
Web: http://www.RuralAndHorseProperties.com
Blogs: http://activerain.com/blogs/brigitam
1 vote Thank Flag Link Mon Oct 5, 2009

I agree with Moriah. A little more detail.....KNBT can not pick the appraiser like in years past. It is now generated through an FHA computer system. Zillow in most cases is way off. I have seen it under value a home as well as over value. The best source is tax records for recent sales. A "BAD NEIGHBORHOOD" is not an adjustment one can take, but rather search for homes in a close proximity and not going back more than 6 months. Also they are going to look for similar homes. Most likely they did not use the one with a garage. And if the subject has 5 bedrooms and a lot more square feet, then they are different and those that you speak of would not be used.
1 vote Thank Flag Link Mon Oct 5, 2009
Hi Natalie,

Be careful when it comes to appraisal the only think that I suggest is
get another appraisal to compared with previous one. or an agent who
specialize in that area, that is my recommendation.
1 vote Thank Flag Link Mon Oct 5, 2009
On a personal note even though I am in the biz.

KNBT did my home equity loan in 2006 - they appraised my house for $40,000 less than I bought it in 2004. I had equity, but was surprised on how low their appraisal came in. They are ultra conservative !!!
Web Reference: http://www.myallied.net
1 vote Thank Flag Link Mon Oct 5, 2009
Search Advice
Ask our community a question
Email me when…

Learn more

Copyright © 2015 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |  
Have a question? Visit our Help Center to find the answer