BEST ANSWER
Silly me...I didn't even answer your main question of being a good board candidate! My apologies...
That changes a few things. Though some lenders will be fine with less than 20% down + PMI, nearly all boards (as I had mentioned) want 20% minimum, while many of them want to see a healthy cash reserve in the bank so they feel comfortable with you (this is why I mentioned leaving your 25k untouched). Not to mention, boards interviews could be like a night out with friends or a tribunal of gestapo officers. Much of it depends on those men and women siting on the board. They will look at your financial history, housing references, job stability (60k is good, but if you started 2 months ago, it may not hold as much weight as a lower paying job you've held for years), character, etc. You're credit, at 770, should be cake. it's also how much they like you, a sad truth. You could be a great candidate for one board and hated by another...a major downside in co-ops. At first glance, you may seem like a good candidate. However, don't forget boards will dig deep! It's difficult to predict how groups of other people think.
The Upside: Have you heard of a sponser co-op? They're great. Basically, they are co-op apartments held by a "sponser". See: http://www.wallfly.com/review/manhattan_ny/glossary.php#s
They typically have a transfer fee/tax, but are exempt form board approval (if you buy a sponser unit, however, and choose to sublet/sell it later, the renter/buyer will then be subject to board approval). They aren't everywhere in FH, but not necessarily uncommon, either. My first apartment purchase was a sponsor. It was a breeze...no board, no hassle, just a 2k transfer that the sponsor agreed to split.
Anyhow, either way, if you have strong finances (less than 20% down, unfortunately doesn't put you in this category with most boards), good references and don't seem like a shady character, a board generally will vote in your favor, barring any other exigent circumstances, of course.
Good luck!
-MC
Sun Oct 11 2009, 09:13