How are appraisals in State College? Is there a method to it? $/square foot? How come you include below grade square footage?

Laura
Home Buyer
State College, PA

We are selling our home in Bucks County and moving to State College, but I'm frustrated by the differences in how pricing is set. In Bucks, appraisers look at above grade square footage only and may give $20K or so for a finished basement. In State College, ranch homes with 2000 square feet above grade are asking $400K...but counting the basement as final square footage. How is that possible? Bucks realtors are discovering that it doesn't matter what you sell the home for, it's the appraiser who sets the actual sales price. Sellers and realtors are fighting like crazy to justify pricing ($/sq foot comps in same neighborhood) and if you property is sold too high, it ends up getting adjusted down to what the appraised value is. So how do sellers justify a 3 bedroom ranch with 2000 above grade with an asking price over $450K--in a state college suburb? Even if you put an offer in, there's no way the comps are there from what I see.

Answers (2)
Linda White
Agent
State College, PA

I think a key factor in your dilemma is that home sellers can ask whatever they want to ask for their home but they may not be able to get it. And we should not disrespect appraisers or lenders who seem to "bring us down to earth" based on current prices of SOLD homes in our location. In your example, it does cost more to build a ranch home than it costs to build a 2-story, for instance. And if a basement is finished or even partially finished, that square footage is noted but it carries less value than finished space above ground level. For example, you may find a home which was valued at $140 per square foot on the above grade square footage and $50 per square foot on the below grade square footage. Either figure could be higher or lower due to the quality of the work on either level. You may find that, comparing prices from Bucks County to Centre County, there is a wide variation based primarily on location. If you are working with a buyer's agent in Centre County, he/she can show you comparable sold properties in your chosen area so you have a better idea of what to offer instead of just giving the seller what he/she is asking. Of course some sellers are reasonable and motivated and others are not. And you should protect yourself by stating that your offer is contingent on an appraised value equal to or greater than the offer price. The bottom line...appraisers and lenders can keep you from paying more than you should for a house. Due to predatory lending and other poor representation in the past, many people have ended up in bad situations. We're all trying to do our part to avoid these issues in the future. If you are not already being represented by an agent in State ColIege, please contact me additional assistance. Linda White, lindawhite@pa.net, 814-571-0804

Tue Oct 27 2009, 19:41
Joni Teaman Spe...
Agent
State College, PA
FIRST ANSWER

The appraisals in State College are based on overall finished square footage, amount of bedrooms and bathrooms, extras in the home (fireplaces& etc,..). The appraisers have to justify their overall price with comps in that general area usually within a short distance and within 3-4 months depending on the banks requirements. There are may factors involved not necessarily the square footage itself determines the pricing. If you would like more specific information, please feel free to contact me for furher assistance at (814) 280-5699 or jonispearly@gmail.com

Tue Oct 27 2009, 17:54

Didn’t find what you were looking for? Ask a question!

Search Advice

Ask a question

Got a real estate question? Get answers from locals, experts and real estate pros.
Ask
Email me when…

Learn more

View all » 1 - 3 of 6
Copyright © 2009 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Help us improve our service—send us feedback