House with old concrete shingles

Wayne Happ
Other/Just Looking
Califon, NJ

I looked at an old house in Clinton that had what they called "cement shingles" on the side. The house is build about 1920. I'm told that these kind of shingles may have asbestos in them, but pose no health risk. (Unless one decides to take them off that is.) Any comments on this?

Answers (8)
David Green
Agent
Cape May County, NJ

Sorry,

I misread the question. lack of sleep I guess. In that case more than lilely they are asbestos and you may want to take a look at this link http://www.epa.gov/asbestos/pubs/ashome.html#4 , it is the US Environmentla protection agency site regarding asbestos.

Good Luck

Tue Jan 8 2008, 11:33
Alan May
Agent
Evanston, IL

David, I think he's referring to siding, since he asked:

"" what they called "cement shingles" on the side "

Tue Jan 8 2008, 10:38
David Green
Agent
Cape May County, NJ

Hi Wayne,

Are you referring to roofing shingles or siding tiles? I think most of the answer posts were thinking of siding tiles also. My exerience with concrete "roofing" tiles has been that they will get to a point in which they start to wick water back into the living area because they have become porous over the years. The concrete roof shingles did not have asbestos but you should have a good roofing company make the determination as to what you have and go from there.

Tue Jan 8 2008, 10:35
Alan May
Agent
Evanston, IL

Wayne, it's only the preferred method because it's expensive to remove them (you have to hire the guys in the space suits and dispose of them properly)... BUT... if they've begun deteriorating, you don't want them continuing to deteriorate underneath your new siding.

I would not choose that option, if you could afford to do it correctly. But hopefully, if you maintain the shingles, they'll last a very very long time.

Fri Dec 28 2007, 08:20
Wayne Happ
Other/Just Looking
Califon, NJ

Thanks everyone. Just wanted to verify what the home inspector told me which was something too the effect. "Take good care of them and keep them painted and they'll last forever. (sic). I was also told that if I decide that I don't want them anymore, the prefered method is to leave them in place and put siding over them.

Fri Dec 28 2007, 07:54
Alan May
Agent
Evanston, IL

Durenda is right on target. Those asbestos tiles, (which do have the appearance of cement) were a wonderful product, with a long durable lifespan. The shingles seem to have a life span of something close to 100 years, if treated well. If not for the fact that they're made with asbestos, I'm sure they'd still be manufacturing them.

My understanding is that as long as they're not deteriorating, they pose no health risk and are an excellent product to leave in place. In fact, just like the asbestos you might fin in an old basement, there's less risk in just leaving them alone, rather than disturbing the

Fri Dec 28 2007, 07:24
Marc Paolella,...
Agent
Succasunna, NJ

They are usually OK if they are not disintegrating. Most people don't remove them, they just side right over them. I'd run it by the building inspector in Clinton and make sure siding over asbestos shingles is legal. If you have to remove them, it could be expensive. Good luck!

Fri Dec 28 2007, 07:14
Durenda Fachtma...
Agent
Coastal Tampa Bay ar...
FIRST ANSWER

Wayne

The asbestos shingles are a very durable product. Most of the time the deterioration is confined to cracked or missing shingles.

Asbestos is purported to produce health risks in it's friable state.

Few companies are qualified to remove and dispose of the asbestos shingle.

Best of luck in your new purchase

Fri Dec 28 2007, 06:38

Didn’t find what you were looking for? Ask a question!

Search Advice

Ask a question

Got a real estate question? Get answers from locals, experts and real estate pros.
Ask
Email me when…

Learn more

View all » 1 - 3 of 17
Copyright © 2009 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Help us improve our service—send us feedback