My list includes:
John Roach- If These Walls Could Talk- 845 625 7214
Mike Christophiles- Granite Inspection Group 845-635-2552
Chuck Sweed Above Grade Home Inspections 845 565 1122
I do agree that Hank Pauli has a great reputation but he is sometimes so busy he may not be able to get to you for more than a week.
I would recommend Josh Stacy of Steadfast home Inspection who also lives in New Paltz. His number is 845-264-3394. He is very thorough so be prepared to spend extra time with him.
Welcome to New Paltz
New Paltz, NY 12561