As a long-time resident of Green Lake myself, I have many suggestions! It really depends on what you're in the mood for. Rosita's Mexican Restaurant features fresh-made tortillas and awesome margaritas! Greenlake Bar & Grill has one of the best happy hour food selections, and you don't have to order an alcoholic beverage to enjoy it either, which is nice. Nell's offers fine dining, while up the road is Spud's which has some of the best fish & chips in the city! Blu-Water Bistro has a great atmosphere, and for dessert, try Zoe Yogurt or Jodee's Desserts!