Both developments are similar. Woodcliff was built by Hovnanian and I do not know who built the Enclosure. I have a family member who lives in the Enclosure. They love it there and have 3 children. It is a great development with lots of children. it is close to Route 9 and it is walking distance to the bus stop. Woodcliff is close to Matawan train station. Woodcliff is hilly and the Enclosure is flat land. I previously owned a Hovnanian home and it was built pretty well and we had no problems with it. I hope this helps.

These neighborhoods are fairly comparable. They are both part of the Marlboro school district which is considered by many to be extremely desireable. The differences between the developments are:
1) The Enclosure is about 5 years older
2) The Enclosure runs alongside Route 18, so some of the homes have that along their backyard.
3) The Enclosure is closer to Route 9, which has a bus to NYC.
4) Woodcliff is closer to the Matawan train station and there is a bus nearby as well.
5) Woodcliff is a larger development than The Enclosure.

I hope that helps!

I am looking to see if there are any issues with the neighborhoods, like noise from Rte 18, environmental issues, lack of parking for commuting to NYC, etc. Also, wanted to know if one is more desirable than the other in terms of future value, schools, etc.

In order to answer your question, I'd have to know a bit about what you are looking for and what is important to you. Everyone's needs and wants are different, and what might be a "con" for one person, might be a "pro" for another.

If you'd like to provide a bit more detail about your needs and wants, I would be able to better answer this question for you.