Ali - you might consider finding a new agent - I don't like to speak ill of anyone, but if "your" (and I assume that means you already have a working relationship) agent isn't being responsive to a simple request......find out why, or find a new agent.
If you are trying to make a decision on something as major as making an offer - this is a discussion you should be having WITH your agent, and not having to look for information/comps on your own!
I'd be happy to help you but I need more information... That said, a good rule of thumb is to compare the median value of the surrounding properties in the neighborhood. If you can buy the property, renovate it and stay within that median value then it is worth the effort and expense of the conversion. Check with town hall. They can give you the property assessments. On average, homes are selling at 105% of their assessment here is Hamilton. For more information, log on to my website to search and analyze homes in Hamilton and Wenham. Good Luck! Let me know if I can be of further assistance.... more