45

Recently Sold Homes in 11964

  • Relevance
    Newest
    Featured
1. Remove some filters or zoom out
2. Save this search to get a heads up when new homes hit the market.
Popular homes in Shelter Island
    1 – 30 of 45 Results
    First Previous Next Last

    Shelter Island Recently Sold Homes

    View assessor property records for Shelter Island NY. The median sales price for homes in Shelter Island NY was $530,000. The average list price for homes for sale in Shelter Island on Trulia is $1,733,706.

    Showing based on selected map area. Don't limit my results by the map.

    1 – 30 of 45 Results
    1 2