Real Estate Overview for Shelter Island


  • Schools
  • Commute
  • Amenities
  • Affordability
  • Demographics
  • Hazards

Average Listing Price

  • $1,288,055
  • for week ending Aug 26
  • -$399
  • -0.0%
  • w-o-w

Median Sales Price

  • $525,000
  • May '15 - Aug '15
  • $92,500
  • -15.0%
  • y-o-y

<
Most popular zip codes Avg. listing Price
Week ending Aug 26
w-o-w
11937 $2,108,835 +0.1%
11743 $883,204 +5.6%
11968 $3,064,159 +2.0%
11746 $596,285 -1.1%
11954 $1,765,531 +2.4%
Movers & Shakers Avg. listing price
Week ending Aug 26
w-o-w
11901 $382,406 -21.7%
11958 $1,393,681 -9.8%
11933 $381,300 -9.5%
11965 $2,177,599 +9.1%
11959 $5,038,888 +8.1%
View Suffolk County Home Prices Map

Summary for Shelter Island


Average price per square foot for Shelter Island NY was $433, a decrease of 40.2% compared to the same period last year. The median sales price for homes in Shelter Island NY for May 15 to Aug 15 was $525,000 based on 3 home sales. Compared to the same period one year ago, the median home sales price decreased 15%, or $92,500, and the number of home sales decreased 62.5%. There are currently 207 resale and new homes in Shelter Island on Trulia, including 4 open houses, as well as 6 homes in the pre-foreclosure, auction, or bank-owned stages of the foreclosure process. The average listing price for homes for sale in Shelter Island NY was $1,288,055 for the week ending Aug 26, which represents a decrease of 0%, or $399, compared to the prior week.


District Type Grades Schools Students
Shelter Island Union Free School District Public K - 12 1 250
School Name School Type Grades Parent Rating
Shelter Island School Public K - 12
View all Shelter Island Schools
  • $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    % Enter a value between 0-100%.
    % Enter a value between 0-30%.
  • $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    % Enter a value between 0-100%.
    $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    Enter a value between 1-30.
Stats & Trends
Homes for Sale in Shelter Island
View all Shelter Island Homes for Sale