Bay Shore Real Estate Market Overview

Could Bay Shore, NY be your next home? Kick-start your search with Trulia’s real estate guide and home search. With interactive maps and charts, Trulia provides a comprehensive overview of market trends, schools, demographics, and lifestyle data to help you learn all about Bay Shore. Not sure which neighborhood is for you? Check out our Nearby Places section below to explore popular cities near Bay Shore such as Ce...ntral Islip and Brentwood. When you’re ready, Trulia has 275 resale and new homes in Bay Shore lined up for you, including 8 open houses, and 513 homes in the pre-foreclosure, auction, or bank-owned stages of the foreclosure process. View more


Median Sales Price

View Homes for sale


Price Per Sqft

View Homes for sale


Median Rent Per Month

View Homes for rent
  • Explore this area:

Housing Market Trends

Market trends help you understand the movement of key price indicators. Trends in Bay Shore show a 2% year-over-year rise in median sales price and a -1% drop in median rent per month.

Median Sales Price
The median sales price for homes in Bay Shore for Mar 23 to Jun 22 was $286,660 based on 58 home sales.
Price Per Square Ft.
Median Rent Per Month
The median rent per month for apartments in Bay Shore for May 23 to Jun 23 was $2,275.


Most frequent crimes in the past year

Knowing more about crime activity in Bay Shore can help keep you aware of crime in the area. Crime activity is most helpful when comparing two locations to understand the relative safety of each location.

View More


Counts of Theft


Counts of Assault


Counts of Vandalism

Best Schools in Bay Shore

There are 11 schools in Bay Shore.

Elementary Schools

South Country School

Public, 3 - 5


Gardiner Manor School

Public, 3 - 5


Hemlock Elementary School

Public, 1 - 5

Middle Schools

Bay Shore Middle School

Public, 6 - 8


West Middle School

Public, 6 - 8

High Schools

Bay Shore Senior High School

Public, 9 - 12


Get to know your neighbors in Bay Shore by reviewing our census driven map. Get insights into median age, how many people are married, and percentage of people with a college degree.

Single residents
Single residents
Home owners
Home owners
Median age
Median age
Household income
Median household income
College educated
College educated


Most people in Bay Shore commute by car. Learn how neighbors in this area get to work so you can consider how you might commute if you lived here, too.

Commute Type
90% commute by car
0% commute by bike
9% commute by public transportation
0% commute by foot

Nearby Cities You May Like