Shelter Island, 11964 Real Estate Overview


  • Schools
  • Commute
  • Amenities
  • Affordability
  • Demographics
  • Hazards

Average Listing Price

  • $2,251,229
  • for week ending Nov 12
  • -$80,104
  • -3.4%
  • w-o-w

Median Sales Price

  • $455,000
  • Aug '14 - Nov '14
  • $143,500
  • -24.0%
  • y-o-y

Average Listing Price $2,251,229 -3.4% w-o-w
Median Sales Price $455,000 -24.0% y-o-y
Average Price/sqft $410 -14.9% y-o-y
Number of Sales 3 -25.0 % y-o-y

Most popular zip codes Avg. listing Price
Week ending Nov 12
w-o-w
11937 $2,557,030 -8.3%
11743 $979,654 -2.6%
11968 $3,890,450 +8.4%
11746 $618,872 -3.3%
11963 $2,868,765 -2.0%
Movers & Shakers Avg. listing price
Week ending Nov 12
w-o-w
11935 $1,157,457 -14.8%
11749 $223,942 -12.6%
11715 $477,072 -11.7%
11944 $806,125 -11.2%
11942 $1,132,930 +10.5%
View Suffolk County Home Prices Map

Summary for Shelter Island, 11964


The median sales price for homes in ZIP code 11964 in Shelter Island from Aug 14 to Nov 14 was $455,000 based on 3 sales. Compared to the same period one year ago, the median sales price decreased 24%, or $143,500, and the number of sales decreased 25%. Average price per square foot for homes in 11964 was $410, an increase of 15.5% compared to the same period last year. There are currently 166 resale and new homes in ZIP code 11964 on Trulia, including 2 open houses, as well as 1 home in the pre-foreclosure, auction, or bank-owned stages of the foreclosure process. The average listing price for homes for sale in 11964 was $2,251,229 for the week ending Nov 12, which represents a decrease of 3.4%, or $80,104, compared to the prior week.


District Type Grades Schools Students
Shelter Island Union Free School District Public K - 12 1 250
School Name School Type Grades Parent Rating
Shelter Island School Public K - 12
View all Shelter Island Schools
  • $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    % Enter a value between 0-100%.
    % Enter a value between 0-30%.
  • $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    % Enter a value between 0-100%.
    $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    Enter a value between 1-30.
Homes for Sale in 11964
View all 11964 Homes for Sale