Montauk, 11954 Real Estate Overview


  • Crime
  • Schools
  • Commute
  • Amenities
  • Affordability
  • Demographics
  • Hazards

Average Listing Price

  • $2,113,069
  • for week ending Sep 10
  • -$36,298
  • -1.7%
  • w-o-w

Median Sales Price

  • $917,500
  • Jun '14 - Sep '14
  • +$212,500
  • +30.1%
  • y-o-y

Average Listing Price $2,113,069 -1.7% w-o-w
Median Sales Price $917,500 +30.1% y-o-y
Average Price/sqft $1045 % y-o-y
Number of Sales 18 -48.6 % y-o-y

Most popular zip codes Avg. listing Price
Week ending Sep 10
w-o-w
11937 $2,713,921 -1.7%
11968 $3,533,675 -1.4%
11743 $1,108,650 +10.0%
11746 $613,112 -1.4%
11954 $2,113,069 -1.7%
Movers & Shakers Avg. listing price
Week ending Sep 10
w-o-w
11958 $1,192,752 -14.3%
11743 $1,108,650 +10.0%
11719 $558,860 -8.7%
11962 $9,961,563 -8.5%
11742 $305,574 +7.6%
View Suffolk County Home Prices Map

Summary for Montauk, 11954


The median sales price for homes in ZIP code 11954 in Montauk from Jun 14 to Sep 14 was $917,500 based on 18 sales. Compared to the same period one year ago, the median sales price increased 30.1%, or $212,500, and the number of sales decreased 48.6%. Average price per square foot for homes in 11954 was $1,045, an increase of 0% compared to the same period last year. There are currently 206 resale and new homes in ZIP code 11954 on Trulia, including 2 open houses, as well as 7 homes in the pre-foreclosure, auction, or bank-owned stages of the foreclosure process. The average listing price for homes for sale in 11954 was $2,113,069 for the week ending Sep 10, which represents a decrease of 1.7%, or $36,298, compared to the prior week.


District Type Grades Schools Students
Montauk Union Free School District Public K - 8 1 321
School Name School Type Grades Parent Rating
Montauk School Public PK - 8
View all Montauk Schools
  • $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    % Enter a value between 0-100%.
    % Enter a value between 0-30%.
  • $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    % Enter a value between 0-100%.
    $ Enter a value greater than 0.
    Enter a value between 1-30.
Homes for Sale in 11954
View all 11954 Homes for Sale