60 Gardiners Bay Drive, Shelter Island NY
60 Gardiners Bay Dr
Keep me posted!
Save this home to compare later!
Back to search |


Est. Mortgage: $19,565 / mo  (Mortgage)

Address Not Disclosed Shelter Island, NY 11964

  • Status: For Sale
  • 4 Bedrooms
  • 3 full, 1 partial Bathrooms
  • Single-Family Home
  • 3,144 sqft
  • Lot size: 0.93 acres
  • Built in 1970
  • 1 Day on Trulia

Home Details for this property

1 Day on Trulia
60 Gardiners Bay Drive
Shelter Island - Original Norman Jaffe Water Front house for sale with sweeping views of Gardiner's Island, Long Beach Point and Plum Gut lighthouse. This 4 bed, 3.5 bath and 2 car attached garage house with heated pool and dock sits on beautifully landscaped .93 acres and boasts amazing water views due North-East. The renowned architect Norman Jaffe designed this house with lots of glass so you have a feeling of nature flowing in and around the house. This is one of three homes located on the same stretch of Shelter Island Waterfront that architect Norman Jaffe was commissioned to desi...gn with each owner's lifestyle in mind.This particular extremely well maintained house has been home to the same family since it was built 44 years ago and was designed with an open floor plan on the first floor that features a long gallery between three bedrooms and the kitchen living area with two sided fireplace. Very much like today's modern floor plans Jaffe incorporated the kitchen into the living space so that one can enjoy being social as well as the amazing water views that captivate you from the moment you step onto the property and into the house. On the second floor he designed the master suite with double height ceiling, steam shower and fireplace that overlooks the bay with an adjoining artist studio that has an oversized window facing the water. Of the three homes Jaffe designed on this site this one was situated further away from the water than the other two as its original owner's felt more comfortable being nestled between the greens of the garden and beautiful specimen trees but still capitalizes on the expansive views of the bay.The home has includes modern features such as AC and forced hot air heat as well as a central vacuum system. It features now protected one of a kind redwood throughout, and on the outside a slate roof as well as the wood decks all around give it that country and waterfront feeling. The pool area is very private beautifully landscaped, features a protected area for sitting while still enjoying views of the bays through the house. Simply said this is a true architectural masterpiece in a magical spot on an amazing island that has managed to keep it's true country character while being within 110 miles to Manhattan.Video tour link: http://youtu.be/Teb5nXO5pTo
Show more
Features for this property

Information last updated on 01/27/2015 12:00 AM:
    • Price: $4,100,000
    • 4 Bedrooms
    • 3 full, 1 partial Bathrooms
    • Single-Family Home
    • Fireplace
    • Status: For Sale
    • Pool
    • Lot Size: 0.93 acres
    • Built in 1970
    • MLS/Source ID: 49002
    • Zip: 11964
    • 3,144 sqft

Public Records for this property

Official property, sales, and tax information from county (public) records as of 10/2013:
    • Single Family Residential
    • 2,579 sqft
    • Stories: 2 story with basement
    • Parking: Garage
    • Basement: Partial Basement
    • Pool: Pool (yes)
    • 4 Bedrooms
    • Lot Size: 0.9 acres
    • A/C: Central
    • Parking Spaces: 2
    • Style: Contemporary
    • County: Suffolk
    • 4 Bathrooms
    • Built In 1970
    • Heating: Central
    • Exterior Walls: Wood
    • Fireplace
    • Tax Rate Code Area: 473201

Neighborhood Info

  • within 2 mile

    See schools ratings

  • See details

  • nearby:

    See details

  • nearby:

    See more routes

Rate and Review area around this property

Rate this area:
Rate these categories:
Restaurant & Shopping
Rate and Review
We need more ratings to calculate an average.

We need more ratings to calculate top categories.

Help us out by sharing your opinion. Do you live, or work near here? What is this area like?


Monthly mortgage for this property

Property Taxes and Assessment for this property

Year Tax Assessment Market
2013 N/A $2,960,000  $2,960,000 
Source: Public Records

Price History & Trends

Compare homes in the area to this property

This Home

Real Estate Trends in 11964

Listing price for this property $4,100,000  
Average listing price for similar homes $3,971,821 3% below listing price
Average listing price for all homes in 11964 $1,631,274 151% below listing price
Median sale price for all homes in 11964 $1,290,000 69% below listing price

Estimates around this property

4 br / 2 ba
Single-Family Home
OPEN HOUSE Sun Oct 16, 2pm to 4pm
  • Home Estimates for this property

    Loading data…

Contact Info

(631) 725-5577
Brown Harris Stevens
Inquire about this property

By sending, you agree to Trulia's Terms of Use & Privacy Policy.

Homes you might like…

Similar Homes