33 New York Ave Shelter Island, NY 11964


33 New York Avenue, Shelter Island NY
33 New York Ave
Keep me posted!
Save this home to compare later!
See similar homes

33 New York Ave
Shelter Island,NY11964

1 of 12
2 of 12
3 of 12
4 of 12
5 of 12
6 of 12
7 of 12
8 of 12
9 of 12
10 of 12
11 of 12
12 of 12

Home Details for 33 New York Ave

180+ Days on Trulia
33 New York Ave Two separate three bedroom, fully functioning homes, located on 1.7 +/- acres in a park-like setting within close proximity to the Ferry, popular beaches and two blocks from restaurants and shopping in the historic Heights District. The main house, completed in 1997, which has beautiful hillside elevations and is surrounded by shade trees and flowering shrubs, features living room with cathedral ceilings and fireplace, formal dining with doors to outdoor deck, cook's kitchen with granite counters, first floor master suite with doors to veranda, two additional guest bedrooms and lower le...vel office with separate entrance. The guest house, built in 2002, offers a sunny living room, full kitchen with granite counters, dining area with fireplace, office with outdoor deck and second floor master suite with recently redone bathroom with double sinks, walk-in shower and soaking tub, as well as two additional bedrooms, all with vaulted ceilings. Located adjacent to a park with skating pond and winter water views this offering is very unique with nearly 5,400 +/- sq. ft. of combined, finished living space in the two dwellings: 2,420 +/- sq. ft. in main house and 2,975 +/- sq. ft. in the guest house. Includes membership in the Heights Beach and Tennis Club and the Shelter Island Golf Club.
Show more
Features for 33 New York Ave

Information last updated on 06/01/2014 12:00 AM:
    • Price: $1,654,000
    • 6 Bedrooms
    • 6 full Bathrooms
    • Single-Family Home
    • Status: For Sale
    • Lot Size: 1.7 acres

Neighborhood Info

  • within 2 mile

    See schools ratings

  • See details

  • nearby:

    See details

  • nearby:

    See more routes

Rate and Review area around 33 New York Ave

Rate this area:
Rate these categories:
Restaurant & Shopping
Rate and Review
We need more ratings to calculate an average.

We need more ratings to calculate top categories.

Help us out by sharing your opinion. Do you live, or work near here? What is this area like?


Monthly mortgage for 33 New York Ave

Price History & Trends

Compare homes in the area to 33 New York Ave

This Home

Real Estate Trends in 11964

Listing price for 33 New York Ave $1,654,000  
Average listing price for similar homes $3,226,733 95% above listing price
Average listing price for all homes in 11964 $2,243,817 26% above listing price
Median sale price for all homes in 11964 $490,000 70% below listing price

Estimates around 33 New York Ave

4 br / 2 ba
Single-Family Home
OPEN HOUSE Sun Oct 16, 2pm to 4pm
  • Home Estimates for 33 New York Ave

    Loading data…

Contact Info

Homes you might like…

Similar Homes