Home > New York homes > Shelter Island homes
Find

Shelter Island homes

for sale
$ to   $

Shelter Island contains 1,487 assessor property records on 115 streets.

South Midway Road homes in 11964
There are 92 homes on South Midway Road. The most recent home sale on S Midway Rd occurred on 07/12/2007.
South Ferry Road homes in 11964
There are 72 homes on South Ferry Road. The most expensive prior home sale on S Ferry Rd had a sales price of $920,000.
North Midway Road homes in 11964
There are 62 homes on North Midway Road. The largest home on N Midway Rd has 5,350 square feet according to public records.
Shorewood Road homes in 11964
There are 56 homes on Shorewood Road. The most recent home sale on Shorewood Rd occurred on 10/05/2006.
Smith Street homes in 11964
There are 54 homes on Smith Street. The most expensive prior home sale on Smith St had a sales price of $875,000.
Lake Drive homes in 11964
There are 43 homes on Lake Drive. The largest home on Lake Dr has 3,802 square feet according to public records.
Saint Marys Road homes in 11964
There are 36 homes on Saint Marys Road. The most recent home sale on Saint Marys Rd occurred on 04/04/2011.
Bay Road homes in 11964
There are 35 homes on Bay Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Bay Rd had a sales price of $1,500,000.
North Cartwright Road homes in 11964
There are 30 homes on North Cartwright Road. The largest home on N Cartwright Rd has 3,262 square feet according to public records.
Menantic Road homes in 11964
There are 30 homes on Menantic Road. The most recent home sale on Menantic Rd occurred on 04/22/2010.
Ram Island Road homes in 11964
There are 29 homes on Ram Island Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Ram Island Rd had a sales price of $2,250,000.
Baldwin Road homes in 11964
There are 29 homes on Baldwin Road. The largest home on Baldwin Rd has 3,304 square feet according to public records.
Congdon Road homes in 11964
There are 27 homes on Congdon Road. The most recent home sale on Congdon Rd occurred on 10/10/2007.
Osprey Road homes in 11964
There are 26 homes on Osprey Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Osprey Rd had a sales price of $855,000.
Cartwright Road homes in 11964
There are 26 homes on Cartwright Road. The largest home on Cartwright Rd has 3,090 square feet according to public records.
North Menantic Road homes in 11964
There are 23 homes on North Menantic Road. The most recent home sale on N Menantic Rd occurred on 08/18/2009.
Dickerson Drive homes in 11964
There are 23 homes on Dickerson Drive. The most expensive prior home sale on Dickerson Dr had a sales price of $1,980,000.
Burns Road homes in 11964
There are 23 homes on Burns Road. The largest home on Burns Rd has 3,142 square feet according to public records.
North Ferry Road homes in 11964
There are 21 homes on North Ferry Road. The most recent home sale on N Ferry Rd occurred on 01/29/2002.
Strawberry Lane homes in 11964
There are 20 homes on Strawberry Lane. The most expensive prior home sale on Strawberry Ln had a sales price of $580,000.
Freds Lane homes in 11964
There are 20 homes on Freds Lane. The largest home on Freds Ln has 4,343 square feet according to public records.
East Thomas Street homes in 11964
There are 20 homes on East Thomas Street. The most recent home sale on E Thomas St occurred on 02/05/2008.
Street Mary's Road homes in 11964
There are 19 homes on Street Mary's Road. The most expensive prior home sale on St Mary's Rd had a sales price of $1,395,000.
South Menantic Road homes in 11964
There are 19 homes on South Menantic Road. The largest home on S Menantic Rd has 3,049 square feet according to public records.
Margarets Drive homes in 11964
There are 19 homes on Margarets Drive. The most recent home sale on Margarets Dr occurred on 05/13/2004.
Country Club Drive homes in 11964
There are 18 homes on Country Club Drive. The most expensive prior home sale on Country Club Dr had a sales price of $885,000.
Tarkettle Road homes in 11964
There are 17 homes on Tarkettle Road. The largest home on Tarkettle Rd has 4,114 square feet according to public records.
Sunshine Road homes in 11964
There are 17 homes on Sunshine Road. The most recent home sale on Sunshine Rd occurred on 03/12/2009.
Merkel Lane homes in 11964
There are 17 homes on Merkel Lane. The most expensive prior home sale on Merkel Ln had a sales price of $5,000,000.
Lakeview Drive homes in 11964
There are 17 homes on Lakeview Drive. The largest home on Lakeview Dr has 2,650 square feet according to public records.
Jaspa Road homes in 11964
There are 17 homes on Jaspa Road. The most recent home sale on Jaspa Rd occurred on 05/11/2006.
Bowditch Road homes in 11964
There are 16 homes on Bowditch Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Bowditch Rd had a sales price of $190,000.
West Neck Road homes in 11964
There are 15 homes on West Neck Road. The largest home on W Neck Rd has 2,962 square feet according to public records.
Thompson Road homes in 11964
There are 15 homes on Thompson Road. The most recent home sale on Thompson Rd occurred on 05/05/2005.
Marc Street homes in 11964
There are 15 homes on Marc Street. The most expensive prior home sale on Marc St had a sales price of $525,000.
Hagar Road homes in 11964
There are 15 homes on Hagar Road. The largest home on Hagar Rd has 3,133 square feet according to public records.
Shelterlands Path homes in 11964
There are 14 homes on Shelterlands Path. The most recent home sale on Shelterlands Path occurred on 02/03/2005.
Quaker Path homes in 11964
There are 14 homes on Quaker Path. The most expensive prior home sale on Quaker Path had a sales price of $450,000.
Sleepy Hollow Road homes in 11964
There are 13 homes on Sleepy Hollow Road. The largest home on Sleepy Hollow Rd has 3,593 square feet according to public records.
Wade Road homes in 11964
There are 12 homes on Wade Road. The most recent home sale on Wade Rd occurred on 11/22/2005.
Montclair Avenue homes in 11964
There are 12 homes on Montclair Avenue. The most expensive prior home sale on Montclair Ave had a sales price of $2,900,000.
Ginny Drive homes in 11964
There are 12 homes on Ginny Drive. The largest home on Ginny Dr has 3,312 square feet according to public records.
Emerson Lane homes in 11964
There are 12 homes on Emerson Lane. The most recent home sale on Emerson Ln occurred on 03/16/2001.
Sandpiper Road homes in 11964
There are 11 homes on Sandpiper Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Sandpiper Rd had a sales price of $995,000.
Quail Run homes in 11964
There are 11 homes on Quail Run. The largest home on Quail Run has 2,228 square feet according to public records.
Pheasant Lane homes in 11964
There are 11 homes on Pheasant Lane. The most recent home sale on Pheasant Ln occurred on 09/12/1997.
Peppermill Lane homes in 11964
There are 11 homes on Peppermill Lane. The most expensive prior home sale on Peppermill Ln had a sales price of $230,000.
Fox Hollow Road homes in 11964
There are 11 homes on Fox Hollow Road. The largest home on Fox Hollow Rd has 3,707 square feet according to public records.
West Thomas Street homes in 11964
There are 10 homes on West Thomas Street. The most recent home sale on W Thomas St occurred on 02/29/2000.
Sea Gull Road homes in 11964
There are 10 homes on Sea Gull Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Sea Gull Rd had a sales price of $1,362,500.
South Cartwright Avenue homes in 11964
There are 10 homes on South Cartwright Avenue. The largest home on S Cartwright Ave has 2,442 square feet according to public records.
Evans Road homes in 11964
There are 10 homes on Evans Road. The most recent home sale on Evans Rd occurred on 09/29/2000.
Cove Way homes in 11964
There are 10 homes on Cove Way. The most expensive prior home sale on Cove Way had a sales price of $1,035,000.
Thomas Avenue homes in 11964
There are 9 homes on Thomas Avenue. The largest home on Thomas Ave has 3,535 square feet according to public records.
Robin Lane homes in 11964
There are 9 homes on Robin Lane. The most recent home sale on Robin Ln occurred on 06/18/2004.
Locust Woods Drive homes in 11964
There are 9 homes on Locust Woods Drive. The most expensive prior home sale on Locust Woods Dr had a sales price of $1,090,000.
Linda Road homes in 11964
There are 9 homes on Linda Road. The largest home on Linda Rd has 2,404 square feet according to public records.
North Cartwright Avenue homes in 11964
There are 8 homes on North Cartwright Avenue.
Manhanset Road homes in 11964
There are 8 homes on Manhanset Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Manhanset Rd had a sales price of $1,065,000.
Linda Court homes in 11964
There are 8 homes on Linda Court. The largest home on Linda Ct has 2,522 square feet according to public records.
Johnston Road homes in 11964
There are 8 homes on Johnston Road. The most recent home sale on Johnston Rd occurred on 02/07/1997.
Irene Lane homes in 11964
There are 8 homes on Irene Lane. The most expensive prior home sale on Irene Ln had a sales price of $500,000.
Hudson Avenue homes in 11964
There are 8 homes on Hudson Avenue. The largest home on Hudson Ave has 3,398 square feet according to public records.
Heron Lane homes in 11964
There are 8 homes on Heron Lane. The most recent home sale on Heron Ln occurred on 06/19/2007.
Ferry Road homes in 11964
There are 8 homes on Ferry Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Ferry Rd had a sales price of $530,000.
Valley Road homes in 11964
There are 7 homes on Valley Road. The largest home on Valley Rd has 2,200 square feet according to public records.
Southwick Lane homes in 11964
There are 7 homes on Southwick Lane. The most recent home sale on Southwick Ln occurred on 01/16/2004.
Heritage Drive homes in 11964
There are 7 homes on Heritage Drive. The most expensive prior home sale on Heritage Dr had a sales price of $300,000.
Gazon Road homes in 11964
There are 7 homes on Gazon Road. The largest home on Gazon Rd has 3,374 square feet according to public records.
Charlies Lane homes in 11964
There are 7 homes on Charlies Lane. The most recent home sale on Charlies Ln occurred on 09/13/2000.
Bateman Road homes in 11964
There are 7 homes on Bateman Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Bateman Rd had a sales price of $850,000.
Sheep Pasture Lane homes in 11964
There are 6 homes on Sheep Pasture Lane. The largest home on Sheep Pasture Ln has 2,145 square feet according to public records.
Manwaring Road homes in 11964
There are 6 homes on Manwaring Road. The most recent home sale on Manwaring Rd occurred on 07/09/2002.
Joy Drive homes in 11964
There are 6 homes on Joy Drive.
Dogwood Lane homes in 11964
There are 6 homes on Dogwood Lane. The largest home on Dogwood Ln has 2,669 square feet according to public records.
Conrad Road homes in 11964
There are 6 homes on Conrad Road. The most recent home sale on Conrad Rd occurred on 01/18/2007.
Tuthill Drive homes in 11964
There are 5 homes on Tuthill Drive. The most expensive prior home sale on Tuthill Dr had a sales price of $960,000.
Osprey Lane homes in 11964
There are 5 homes on Osprey Lane. The largest home on Osprey Ln has 3,761 square feet according to public records.
Dinah Rock Road homes in 11964
There are 5 homes on Dinah Rock Road. The most recent home sale on Dinah Rock Rd occurred on 01/28/2002.
Ward Street homes in 11964
There are 4 homes on Ward Street. The most expensive prior home sale on Ward St had a sales price of $765,000.
School Street homes in 11964
There are 4 homes on School Street. The largest home on School St has 2,320 square feet according to public records.
Lari Lane homes in 11964
There are 4 homes on Lari Lane. The most recent home sale on Lari Ln occurred on 04/14/1997.
Deer Park Lane homes in 11964
There are 4 homes on Deer Park Lane. The most expensive prior home sale on Deer Park Ln had a sales price of $937,500.
Williette Road homes in 11964
There are 3 homes on Williette Road. The largest home on Williette Rd has 1,495 square feet according to public records.
Sunset Lane homes in 11964
There are 3 homes on Sunset Lane.
Simpson Avenue homes in 11964
There are 3 homes on Simpson Avenue. The most expensive prior home sale on Simpson Ave had a sales price of $68,000.
Seagate Road homes in 11964
There are 3 homes on Seagate Road. The largest home on Seagate Rd has 2,304 square feet according to public records.
Duvall Road homes in 11964
There are 3 homes on Duvall Road. The most recent home sale on Duvall Rd occurred on 10/06/2004.
Cockles Place homes in 11964
There are 3 homes on Cockles Place. The most expensive prior home sale on Cockles Pl had a sales price of $125,000.
Bonnie Lane homes in 11964
There are 3 homes on Bonnie Lane. The largest home on Bonnie Ln has 3,534 square feet according to public records.
Apple Orchard Place homes in 11964
There are 3 homes on Apple Orchard Place.
Willow Pond Road homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on Willow Pond Road. The most expensive prior home sale on Willow Pond Rd had a sales price of $189,500.
South Ram Island Drive homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on South Ram Island Drive. The largest home on S Ram Island Dr has 2,304 square feet according to public records.
Propose Road homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on Propose Road. The most recent home sale on Propose Rd occurred on 10/30/1998.
Primrose Place homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on Primrose Place. The most expensive prior home sale on Primrose Pl had a sales price of $485,000.
Lords Lane homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on Lords Lane.
Little Ram Island Drive homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on Little Ram Island Drive.
Graces Lane homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on Graces Lane. The most expensive prior home sale on Graces Ln had a sales price of $600,000.
Crescent Way homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on Crescent Way. The largest home on Crescent Way has 2,555 square feet according to public records.
Bartman Road homes in 11964
There are 2 homes on Bartman Road.
1 2
Nearby Cities

Cities
Median
sales price
Average
listing price
$406,250
$769,970
$410,000
$913,370
$382,020
$846,658
$950,000
$2,220,302
$832,038
$1,023,432
$1,780,000
$1,390,751
Shelter Island Zip Code Property Records
Copyright © 2014 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |  
Have a question? Visit our Help Center to find the answer