The lots are smaller in Highland Park and since these were built in the 90s, you will run into more outdated interiors in Highland Park than Bonbrook. Bonbrook is also a smaller community than Highland Park.
Highland Park is extremely close to the high school. Some people think that's great. Others may not. It depends on whether that's attractive to you or not. But essentially, school aged children could walk to both elementary and high school from Highland Park.
Highland Park will have more family community amenities with: pool, playground, park, clubhouse, and tennis. Bonbrook has a playground and walking trails.
Lastly, Highland Park is, as it's been said, closer to I65 and Cool Springs. Bonbrook is on Concord Road.
So it really depends on what is most important to you! - Thu May 21 2009, 15:27