• Min Price
  • Max Price
  • All Beds
  • All Baths
  • Property Type
Allowed Pets
Furnishing
Square Feet
Square Feet
Landlord Pays
Landlord Pays
Listing Features New
Unit Amenities
Unit Amenities
Building Amenities
Building Amenities
Reset
Updating Results

Shelter Island Apartments For Rent

289 Results
  • Featured
  • Relevance
  • Newest
  • Price
  • More
  • Featured
  • Newest
  • Price
  • Apt. Communities
  • More
  • Newest
  • Price
  • Price / Sqft
  • Bedrooms
  • More

Showing based on selected map area. Don't limit my results by the map.

You know what you want.
Unfortunately nothing matches this search criteria. Try removing a filter or two

Or check out these popular homes


Summary for Shelter Island


Average price per square foot for Shelter Island NY was $936, an increase of 162.2% compared to the same period last year. The median sales price for homes in Shelter Island NY for Oct 14 to Jan 15 was $1,285,000 based on 4 home sales. Compared to the same period one year ago, the median home sales price increased 133.6%, or...

31 - 45 of 289 Apts
1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 20
  • Now displaying of 289 Results.
  • Zoom in or apply search filters.
Featured
Newest
Featured
    Loading Results

    Sorry, no results in this area.

    Try moving the map
    or changing your filters.

    Show More Results