NOTE: This post will be continually updated, below, as more foreclosure freeze news breaks.I double-dog dare you to watch a TV news show or spend more than 5 minutes on the web without hearing about the massive "robo-signing" foreclosure scandal that is rapidly encompassing the biggest banks in the country. Here are 4 things home buyers need to know about this breaking real estate news, and how it impacts them.
(Hint: I threw in a couple of bonus items at the end!)
1. What is robo-signing is, and what all the fuss is about? The phrase robo-signing refers to what we’re now realizing has been a very common practice in the banks’ foreclosure document processing divisions, where one person was essentially given the job of signing as many 10,000 foreclosure documents per month, by hand. These individuals were supposed to be reviewing the files, making sure grounds for foreclosure actually existed, signing the docs in front of notaries. But because of the volume of documents, what they actually did was just sign thousands of documents at a time, without even reading them, and ship them off somewhere else to be notarized.
If you do the math on an 8 hour workday, you'll see that that only gives the staffer 1.5 minute to review each file and documents to make sure the foreclosure is warranted. That's not humanly possible, which is how these staffers got the nickname “robo-signers”
Government regulators are very concerned that the banks may have been taking people's homes without following the proper legal procedures. As a result, 40 states' attorneys general are teaming up to launch a multi-state investigation, and the federal Comptroller of the Currency and federal attorney general may also get involved in investigating this issue.
2. Will the freeze will make the banks cancel buyer contracts on REO properties? Currently, the freeze impacts bank-owned properties that are owned and/or serviced by Ally Financial/GMAC Mortgage, JP Morgan Chase, and some properties that were owned by Bank of America. Generally, contracts to buy these homes are being put on hold and extended for 30 days. As well, the banks are often reaching out directly to buyers and offering them the option to cancel their contracts and recoup their deposit money.
3. Is it safe to buy a foreclosed home? There's lots of talk right now about the "clouds" that this scandal will create on the titles to homes that were foreclosed by the banks' foreclosure mills. And that makes sense: if the home wasn't properly foreclosed on in the first place, then the legitimacy of the bank's resale can be called into question. Normally, I'd say: Don't worry about it, buyer - that's why you'll get title insurance! But last week, 3 of America's largest title company insurers declared that they will not offer title insurance on a number of the homes that may have been involved in this scandal.
In the vast majority of cases – when the foreclosure was justified and a bona fide purchaser, someone who was not involved in the bank’s wrongdoing, has purchased the home, courts will not reverse these foreclosures or their sale to buyers. But if you’re in the market for a foreclosure, get clear on which bank owns the place as soon as you can, and run the property past your title insurer before you get too far into the transaction to make sure they can write a policy of title insurance on the property before you spend too much money on inspections and appraisals. (And see my Bonus Buyer Advice at the end of this blog post!)
4. How the foreclosure freeze will impact American home values, say after you buy. In the short term, these freezes might cause prices to stabilize, as we expect to see the supply of foreclosures for sale start to shrink. However, if these freezes stretch out for a long period of time, they could simply be delaying many inevitable foreclosures, which could delay the recovery of the housing market and home prices, over time. I wouldn't expect to see the freezes cause prices to drop much beyond where they are now, but if they stretch out, they could keep appreciation flat for a longer period of time.
P.S. - Bonus Buyer Advice from Tara: Don’t underestimate the deals you can get on non-foreclosed properties. You can often get just as good of a price on a better property with more flexibility on the seller’s part in terms of repairs and other negotiation points if you buy a home from an individual seller, as opposed to a bank-owned property.
P.P.S. - Click here for more tips on
how to negotiate the best possible deal when you buy a home.
P.P.P.S. - You should follow Trulia and Tara on Facebook, too!Update 10.12.2010 - Litton Loan Servicing and PNC Financial have also implemented foreclosure moratoria. Details to come.
Update 10.18.2010 - Many have written to ask me whether any Fannie Mae-owned properties are affected. Bank of America, in particular, services many Fannie Mae-owned homes. The short answer is that yes - many Fannie Mae REO sales ARE frozen, for the time being.
Fannie Mae says: "
Fannie Mae has halted foreclosures, evictions, and
REO sale closings when necessary for a servicer to perform required
remediation. Our actions are intended to protect the rights of
borrowers facing foreclosure, enable a fair and equitable legal process
for all impacted parties and allow new homebuyers to close on their
transactions in a timely manner."
Update 10.19.2010 - Bank of America says it will "effectively" lift the foreclosure freeze in the 23 judicial foreclosure states, beginning next week - click here for more details.
Update 10.29.2010 - Wells Fargo has announced that it will re-file foreclosure documents in 55,000 foreclosure cases - the first indication the bank has ever given that there might have been "issues" with its foreclosure document processes. click here for more details
Comments
That is so helpful and I love your blog. Thanks.
Great advice and I especially like the bonus remarks. Buyers are demanding and getting givebacks from motovated sellers who have priced their homes well.
Your blog is full of relevant information. Thanks!
US Government Plans to Resolve "Foreclosure-Gate" ~ http://ping.fm/qmnPl
- We dont know if that is the case or not, because this is uncharted water. Additionally, If the title insurance doesn't kick in are the people that bought these homes really going to have the money to go to court and fight for their homes? I think the only people that will win when this shakes our are the attorneys. . . . Additionally, this article fails to mention the issue about MERS and how title has been transferred on these homes when the banks sold the loans, another potential problem that plays into this.
The Happy House Guy
@Tracy Harding:
Yes, you would have grounds against the bank to collect commission, however, it would be the listing agent that would have to fight for it in order for you to get your co-broke as a buyer's agent.
(Disclaimer - I am not an attorney)
MERS was put into place so that banks could start offering mortgage backed securities to investors. The promissory notes were sold to investors the day the buyer closed on their home loan. When a promissory note is satisfied then the collateral is supposed to become free and clear. No one owns the promissory notes anymore. They were sliced and diced and packaged into mortgage backed securities. The deed of trust or mortgage was assigned to MERS as nominee and then another servicer started collecting house payments. The servicer doesn't own the loan. MERS doesn't own the loan. The original lender didn't lend any money because the investor provided it. No one holds the promissory note and that is the only legal document that can give anyone legal standing to go into court and foreclose on a property. So this is not about robo-signers. This is about pure fraud throughout the mortgage system. Everyone who has a MERS mortgage has probably been making payments to some entity that never loaned them money. They will have a clouded title when it comes time for them to sell their home.
And all is right with the World...
Tara thanks for a great snapshot though!
Marcus, I had to go looking for further information in alternative media such as zerohedge.com or market-ticker.com because I've learned that the sound bytes that passes for news in the mainstream media is never the whole story. What I've learned is mind boggling. It's certainly your prerogative to put on your happy face and pretend this is just fear tactics by the media but the fact is, this is going to affect the real estate market and beyond. I'm guessing that the banks will whine to congress who will propose yet another bank bailout, even as some of them are making record profits and paying big bonuses. I don't think it would be difficult to imagine the outrage of The People should something like that come to pass. I've been considering what might happen, and with the exception of the possibility of a few more sales of non-short sale/foreclosed properties in the short term, while foreclosures are temporarily off the market, I can think of nothing good that can come of this.
On Wednesday, all 50 states launched a joint investigation of the mortgage industry after widespread reports of mortgage industry officials signing foreclosure documents without knowing their contents
Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller, who's heading the bipartisan investigation, said "......This is a chance to right the law and get the process right, a chance to have some extra time ... and maybe a chance to do some modifications.
http://activerain.com/blogs/tonyglewis
That's the background - here's the simple question: what are the implications of this for an already done foreclosure? Something? Nothing? Stay tuned? Any info is better than none!
When you think it is safe to go into the water....Sharks!!!
What is the Big Picture here?? Look past the obvious and prepare for the worst.
The Title company is the insurance company...mmmm...The banks are the wrong
doers...mmmm.... one + one = ____.
Now during the Equity Gold Rush where thousands of home owners pulled out
hundreds of thousands of dollars with the intentions of not paying it back...
Is this a form of extortion?? WHO IS EXTORTING WHO?
Where did all that money come from? Who is responsible for all this debt?
They want to let the house go and cry poor me...try not having anything to eat
for 2 days and your utilities turned off for a month..feel the real pain of America.
You can tell who did it..Look at the Hummers,RV,Boat and jewelry.
This is Election time!! POWER TO THE PEOPLE!! Make your vote count !
A couple of things:
1) The New York Times has reported that Fannie Mae HAS frozen resales of Fannie-owned homes which were formerly owned by B of A.
2) @Jeremy D. - Actually, the issue of an innocent buyer purchasing a home from someone who might have obtained title illegitimately is an age-old issue in real estate and title law. As such, there is a well-settled rule of law in many jurisdictions under which bona fide purchasers (real estate buyers who paid value who were innocent of any wrongdoing) take valid title, and courts will not undo or reverse the sale - even if the transfer was fraudulent or the seller's title illegitimately obtained.
Check out: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bona_fide_purchaser
So, I do think it's safe to say that, where the bona fide purchaser rule reigns, IF the foreclosure was justified (and sometimes even if it wasn't) and IF the buyer was innocent, most courts will avoid unwinding the sale to an innocent purchaser. If the court finds wrongdoing in the course of the foreclosure, their preference would be to award damages to the foreclosed homeowner, rather than penalize the new, innocent buyer.
@Everyone: I have been hearing a lot of agents stating that short sales are getting delayed - even more! - as a result of this issue. Please continue to update us and let us know what you're experiencing in that respect.
More to come. . .and thanks so much for your feedback!
Thank you for all the useful info. I think the part about checking to see if the buyers title company will cover the title,early, is really important info.
Great t information, The National Association of Attorneys General announced today that 49 states would be participating in the investigation, Top legal officers of all 50 states opened a joint investigation into home foreclosures, saying they will seek an immediate halt to any improper practices at banks and mortgage companies.
The states will conduct a coordinated inquiry into whether banks and loan servicers used false documents and signatures to justify hundreds of thousands of foreclosures. The group intends to establish independent monitoring, Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller, who is leading the probe, said today in a statement.
“The financial institutions would be well served by working with us to get it cleaned up,” Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray told Bloomberg Television’s “InBusiness with Margaret Brennan.” “And they’d also be well served to think about reaching negotiated resolutions with borrowers in cases where they’ve created exposure for themselves by committing fraud upon the courts.”
Foreclosure Defense Attorneys will gave us update on this topic, find one in your area
"Angie" Mamian
Buyers certainly should beware that there is increased risk in buying a foreclosure of the banks involved. The fact that title insurers are staying away, clearly demonstrates they believe there is an opening for challenging these foreclosures and they're not willing to insure them!
Also, I know several people who were in the midst of loan modification when the bank suddenly foreclosed on them. They called and called and called and called the bank and finally got resolution in their favor. As frustrating as it is, being persistent seems to pay off.
==========
Savings Interest Rates
http://santaclaritavalleyshortsalerealtor.com and http://stopforeclosuresantaclaritavalley.info.
craigslist austin,
http://santaclaritavalleyshortsalerealtor.com
http://stopforeclosuresantaclaritavalley.info
Thanks for the quality information
Nat
http://www.YourCtFHAMortgage.com
I would do listen to the actual transsactions and transactors because that's what's really going on in real time.
But to take it a little personal, I think we the Real Estate Agents and Brokers are the real reason or at least a big part of all of this big problem that is going on
We want to sell Homes, Regular sale, short sale, Foreclosures, probates whatever comes our way; we are on calling FSBO, Expireds. we want to be up to date with technology, with all new designations and information to better SALE homes The Loan Officers want to do ALL kinds of loan Products........... admitedly,,,,,,we are greedy.
We need to stop all of this none sense. Stop listing REO's and Short sales. Let us, all of us: RE agents do just and only list Regular normal sales. Let the Banks handle their own, hire their own licensed Bank Sales personel and Loan officers and watch how they go Down with their Millions down the drain, There would be only one Bank The Right one that will do the right thing. Look at the New Home sellers, They have their own agents, most of the time they will do their own loans (they used to). We have the Power to stop all this Hype.
We have a negative image in front of all consumers as greedy, malicious people. The potential clients see a person with a Suit and Tie and inmidiatly think: "Real Estate Agent or Religious recruiter" I want to be seen as a hero, some one who help them sell their home for profit and someone who help a buyer get their Dream Home, with Local Community Down Payment Assistance. I'm just sick and tired of all of this "cycles" let there be no "cycles" But is just ones dream, an impossible dream, or is it.?
craigslist austin,