Refine Search Start over


Shelter Island, NY
[clear]
More neighborhood options

Custom price range



Custom beds/baths range



Info


Select multiple property types

Custom sqft range

More search options


 to 




 to 

Shelter Island Real Estate & Homes For Sale

 — 202 homes found
address
price
x br x ba xxxx sqft $xxx/sqft
prop_type
nhood
school address

Showing nearby homes for sale
  
 Expand Map
 
$4,495,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
2 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

6 br  /  6 ½ ba  /  6,000 sqft  /  $749/sqft

prudentialelliman.com

 

Source: prudentialelliman.com

Broker: Dorothy Herman

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 2009

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Highly regarded for their artful design and craftsman sense of detailing, internationally recognized Morris Sato Studio has created…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$1,895,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  4,250 sqft  /  $446/sqft

Single-Family Home

1townandcountry.com

 

Source: 1townandcountry.com

Agent: Alicia Ward

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Enjoy all the luxury of quality new construction: Builder's newly constructed home on 1 beautiful Shelter Island acre with 4 bedrooms,…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$800,000 30 Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island NY
30 Brander Parkway, Shelter Island NY
28 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba  /  1,933 sqft  /  $414/sqft

Single-Family Home

Prudential Douglas Elliman…

 

Source: Prudential Douglas Elliman…

Agent: Glen Hagen, LSA, e-PRO

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 2000

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This Custom, All Vinyl, Maintenance-Free Home, Built Very Recently (2000) in Silver Beach on a Spacious 3/4 Acre Property is Awaiting…

View full details on 30 Brander Pkwy Compare similar homes to 30 Brander Pkwy
$1,895,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
16 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  4,250 sqft  /  $446/sqft

Single-Family Home

prudentialelliman.com

 

Source: prudentialelliman.com

Broker: Dorothy Herman

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 2007

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
So much more for your money on Shelter Island, this beautiful new 4 bedroom 4,250 sf home is located on one acre on a quiet street…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$799,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

REDUCED by $76,000 (8.7%) on Sep 26, 2009

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba  /  1,700 sqft  /  $470/sqft

Single-Family Home

vlshomes.com

Source: vlshomes.com

Agent: Janalyn Messer

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1985

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Owner Motivated. First time on the market and in move in condition. Spacious 3BR, 2BA Ranch with large back overlooking…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$839,000 29 Osprey Rd, Shelter Island NY
29 Osprey Road, Shelter Island NY
12 photos

REDUCED by $10,000 (1.2%) on Sep 28, 2009

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ba

Single-Family Home

1townandcountry.com

Source: 1townandcountry.com

Broker: Town and Country Real Estate…

Agent: Nicholas J. Planamento

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1900

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
European Inspired Home At Ward's Point On Shy Half Acre. Experience Shelter Island At Its Best And Most Private. Membership In…

View full details on 29 Osprey Rd Compare similar homes to 29 Osprey Rd
$875,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

REDUCED by $50,000 (5.4%) on Sep 26, 2009

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ½ ba  /  2,208 sqft  /  $396/sqft

Single-Family Home

vlshomes.com

Source: vlshomes.com

Agent: Georgiana B. Ketcham

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1993

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND SECLUDED RURAL TRADITIONAL- 1.5 acres end of cul de sac, back yard borders open space preserve. 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths,…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$1,795,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
2 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  3,000 sqft  /  $598/sqft

Single-Family Home

prudentialelliman.com

Source: prudentialelliman.com

Broker: Dorothy Herman

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 2006

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Located in the desirable Shorewood area (which offers community tennis and private beach access for resident's only) this new…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$899,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

REDUCED by $26,000 (2.8%) on Sep 22, 2009

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ½ ba  /  2,382 sqft  /  $377/sqft

Single-Family Home

vlshomes.com

Source: vlshomes.com

Agent: Georgiana B. Ketcham

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND GREATFIELDS- A house for the ages- from the late 1770's to the 21st century, this beautiful, very liveable home…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$1,595,000 23 Osprey Rd, Shelter Island NY
23 Osprey Road, Shelter Island NY
12 photos

REDUCED by $200,000 (11.1%) on Nov 7, 2009

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  3,000 sqft  /  $532/sqft

Single-Family Home

corcoran.com

Source: corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
BEACH COMMUNITY TRADITIONALpGracious new 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath home in beautiful Shorewood area of Shelter Island. Lovely design features…

View full details on 23 Osprey Rd Compare similar homes to 23 Osprey Rd
$2,750,000 6 Conrad Rd, Shelter Island NY
6 Conrad Road, Shelter Island NY
12 photos

NEW CONSTRUCTION

by () on

OPEN ,

5 br  /  5 ½ ba

Single-Family Home

prudentialelliman.com

Source: prudentialelliman.com

Broker: Prudential Douglas Elliman…

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: New construction

Year Built: 2004

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Attention To Detail And Quality Craftsmanship In This Beautiful Traditional Set On .75 Acres.Gracious Entertaining.

View full details on 6 Conrad Rd Compare similar homes to 6 Conrad Rd
$19,900,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
8 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

12 br  /  12 ba  /  12,000 sqft  /  $1,658/sqft

Single-Family Home

bhshamptons.com

Source: bhshamptons.com

Broker: Brown Harris Stevens Bridge…

Agent: Christopher Burnside

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1900

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
An extraordinary offering, this singular 24.81acre waterfront property provides an unprecedented 1,500' of pristine beach frontage…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$3,400,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
8 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

6 br  /  4 ½ ba  /  3,157 sqft  /  $1,077/sqft

Single-Family Home

bhshamptons.com

Source: bhshamptons.com

Broker: Brown Harris Stevens Sag Ha…

Agent: Caroline Sarraf

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1860

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This magnificent Italianate Victorian residence c.1860 presides over 2.94acres of lushly landscaped property on scenic Menantic Creek…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
$750,000 Address Not Disclosed
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
11 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

2 br  /  2 ba

Single-Family Home

sothebysrealty.com

Source: sothebysrealty.com

Broker: Daniel Gale Sotheby's…

Agent: Elizabeth M. Gilpin

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1950

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This is a magnificent opportunity for someone who would love to be on Shelter Island and have plenty of acreage to build an estate.…

View full details on this property Compare similar homes to this property
< Prev 
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 19
 Next > 
0 properties matched your search.
Try these search tips:
  • Broaden your search by expanding your search criteria.
  • Expand your search area to include more areas.
  • Set up an email alert to get notified when listings come on the market.
Try a new search Sign up for listing alerts
Local Spotlight
  Your ad here  
Copyright © 2009 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Help us improve our service—send us feedback





Updating results...
[x]
,
Showing address and nearby
homes for sale
View all homes in