Shelter Island, NY Real Estate & Homes For Sale

21 homes

  • 27 S  Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    NEW - 2 DAYS AGO0.72 ACRES
    $1,295,000
    3bd
    3ba
    1,512 sqft (on 0.72 acres)
    27 S Ferry Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Corcoran Group (Shelter Island)
  • 47-B S  Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    1.74 ACRES
    $3,995,000
    3bd
    2ba
    1,800 sqft (on 1.74 acres)
    47-B S Ferry Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
  • 10 B Sunshine Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    0.92 ACRES
    $3,200,000
    4bd
    5ba
    5,300 sqft (on 0.92 acres)
    10 B Sunshine Road,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
  • 73 N  Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    1.26 ACRES
    $1,445,000
    4bd
    4ba
    1,900 sqft (on 1.26 acres)
    73 N Cartwright Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
  • 70 S  Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    1.3 ACRES
    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
  • 11 Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    1.3 ACRES
    $4,550,000
    4bd
    5ba
    3,000 sqft (on 1.30 acres)
    11 Dickerson Dr,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Sotheby's International Realty
  • 45B Lake Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    1.6 ACRES
    Listing by: M WEIN REALTY INC
  • 3 Sea Gull Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    0.61 ACRES
    $1,975,000
    3bd
    3ba
    1,650 sqft (on 0.61 acres)
    3 Sea Gull Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Brown Harris Stevens
  • 56A N  Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    1.16 ACRES
    Listing by: READ CHRISTOPHER M
  • 47L S  Ferry Rd   S, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    NEW CONSTRUCTION0.91 ACRES
    $9,900,000
    4bd
    4ba
    3,800 sqft (on 0.91 acres)
    47L S Ferry Rd S,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
  • 115 S  Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    1.16 ACRES
    $5,250,000
    6bd
    6ba
    5,500 sqft (on 1.16 acres)
    115 S Ferry Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
  • 20F S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    0.5 ACRES
    $1,275,000
    3bd
    2ba
    1,161 sqft (on 0.50 acres)
    20F S Ferry Road,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
  • 34 N  Cartwright Rd #A, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    2.1 ACRES
    $19,975,000
    5bd
    5ba
    4,490 sqft (on 2.10 acres)
    34 N Cartwright Rd #A,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Saunders & Associates
  • 44 Saint Marys Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    8.15 ACRES
    $4,495,000
    4bd
    5ba
    4,478 sqft (on 8.15 acres)
    44 Saint Marys Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Brown Harris Stevens
  • 5 Sea Gull Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    0.68 ACRES
    $3,100,000
    5bd
    5ba
    3,072 sqft (on 0.68 acres)
    5 Sea Gull Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Saunders & Associates
  • LOT 3a B Pandion Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    NEW CONSTRUCTION6 ACRES
    $6,999,000
    5bd
    5ba
    6,000 sqft (on 6 acres)
    LOT 3a B Pandion Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Compass
  • 4 Duvall Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    0.5 ACRES
    $1,350,000
    2bd
    2ba
    1,200 sqft (on 0.50 acres)
    4 Duvall Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Simon Harrison Real Estate
  • 81 N  Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    0.38 ACRES
    $1,750,000
    4bd
    3ba
    2,264 sqft (on 0.38 acres)
    81 N Midway Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Saunders & Associates
  • 28 Smith St, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    0.34 ACRES
    $1,350,000
    3bd
    2ba
    1,421 sqft (on 0.34 acres)
    28 Smith St,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Simon Harrison Real Estate
  • 7 S  Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    6 ACRES
    $4,850,000
    3bd
    2ba
    1,784 sqft (on 6 acres)
    7 S Cartwright Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: M WEIN REALTY INC
  • 3 Pandion Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    6 ACRES
    Listing by: Compass

Homes Near Shelter Island, NY

We found 29 more homes matching your filters just outside Shelter Island

  • 26 Mashomuck Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    NEW - 3 HRS AGO1.5 ACRES
    $11,750,000
    6bd
    8ba
    8,500 sqft (on 1.50 acres)
    26 Mashomuck Dr,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Compass
  • 43 Harbor Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    NEW - 1 DAY AGONEW CONSTRUCTION0.28 ACRES
    $5,750,000
    4bd
    4ba
    3,300 sqft (on 0.28 acres)
    43 Harbor Dr,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Corcoran Group
  • 51 Forest Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    0.66 ACRES
    Listing by: Brown Harris Stevens
  • 27 Sunset Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    NEW CONSTRUCTION0.44 ACRES
    $5,250,000
    6bd
    8ba
    4,200 sqft (on 0.44 acres)
    27 Sunset Rd,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Saunders & Associates
  • 9 Behringer Ln, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    2 ACRES
    $1,999,000
    3bd
    3ba
    2,780 sqft (on 2 acres)
    9 Behringer Ln,
    Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
    Listing by: Saunders & Associates
  • 1000 9th Street UNIT G56, Greenport, NY 11944
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    Listing by: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
  • 47 On The Blfs, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Use arrow keys to navigate
    2.27 ACRES
    $5,750,000
    5bd
    6ba
    5,070 sqft (on 2.27 acres)
    47 On The Blfs,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Compass
  • 28 Windermere Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    0.3 ACRES
    Listing by: Saunders & Associates
  • 109 N  Haven Way, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    1.86 ACRES
    Listing by: Compass
  • 4295 Bay Shore Rd, Greenport, NY 11944
    Listing by: Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
  • 20 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    1.2 ACRES
    $5,450,000
    7bd
    6ba
    5,000 sqft (on 1.20 acres)
    20 Prospect Ave,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
  • 55 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    1.26 ACRES
    $9,950,000
    5bd
    6ba
    7,500 sqft (on 1.26 acres)
    55 Shore Rd,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Bespoke Real Estate
  • 42 Mashomuck Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    1.03 ACRES
    $4,895,000
    4bd
    3ba
    3,300 sqft (on 1.03 acres)
    42 Mashomuck Dr,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Saunders & Associates
  • 96 NW Landing Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937
    1.72 ACRES
    $8,350,000
    4bd
    5ba
    3,374 sqft (on 1.72 acres)
    96 NW Landing Rd,
    East Hampton, NY 11937
    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
  • 11 Terry Road, East Hampton, NY 11937
    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
  • 11 Terry Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    0.25 ACRES
    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
  • 169 N  Ferry Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
    1.36 ACRES
    Listing by: Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
  • 19 Crooked Hwy, East Hampton, NY 11937
    4.03 ACRES
    $4,495,000
    6bd
    7ba
    5,000 sqft (on 4.03 acres)
    19 Crooked Hwy,
    East Hampton, NY 11937
    Listing by: Compass
  • 508 4th Street, Greenport, NY 11944
    Listing by: Compass Greater NY LLC
  • 5 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    1.06 ACRES
    $1,675,000
    3bd
    3ba
    2,380 sqft (on 1.06 acres)
    5 Country Club Dr,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
  • 348 Ferry Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    0.88 ACRES
    $2,350,000
    4bd
    3ba
    3,462 sqft (on 0.88 acres)
    348 Ferry Rd,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
  • 5 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
    NEW CONSTRUCTION0.25 ACRES
    $3,750,000
    3bd
    3ba
    1,760 sqft (on 0.25 acres)
    5 Grand Ave,
    Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
    Listing by: Corcoran Group
  • 5 Mimosa Pl, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    $1,650,000
    4bd
    2ba
    1,604 sqft
    5 Mimosa Pl,
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Listing by: Dering Harbor Real Estate
  • 23 Bridge St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    0.29 ACRES
    $4,250,000
    1bd
    2ba
    3,000 sqft (on 0.29 acres)
    23 Bridge St,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Compass
  • 12 Rose St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    $2,175,000
    2bd
    2ba
    2,670 sqft
    12 Rose St,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Compass
  • 8 Rose St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    $1,975,000
    3bd
    2ba
    1,500 sqft
    8 Rose St,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Compass
  • 11 Sunset Beach Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    2.02 ACRES
    Listing by: Compass
  • 3 Taft Pl, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    0.51 ACRES
    $6,295,000
    5bd
    7ba
    5,700 sqft (on 0.51 acres)
    3 Taft Pl,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
  • 25 Redcoats Ln, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    NEW CONSTRUCTION1.84 ACRES
    $8,995,000
    7bd
    10ba
    7,000 sqft (on 1.84 acres)
    25 Redcoats Ln,
    Sag Harbor, NY 11963
    Listing by: Compass

Shelter Island, NY Real Estate Trends

Learn about the Shelter Island, NY housing market through trends and averages.

Affordability of Living in Shelter Island, NY

The median home value is $1,251,058
MonthMedian home value
November 2023$1.24M
December 2023$1.24M
January 2024$1.25M
View as a graph
Trends and affordability stats are provided by third party data sources.

Average Home Value in Shelter Island, NY, by Home Size

Currently, there are 2 new listings and 21 homes for sale in Shelter Island.
Home SizeHome Value*
2 bedrooms (1 home)$902,804
3 bedrooms (7 homes)$1,147,422
4 bedrooms (6 homes)$1,676,986
*Home value over the past month

What Locals Say about Shelter Island

  • Christina D.
    "I have lived here for the past four months and felt a sense of community and one with the natural beauty and peaceful restful ambiance"
    3
    Flag
  • Joseph L.
    "I love dogs but some owners are very rude by letting dogs off their leash in public beaches and parks Very rude"
    3
    Flag
  • Justinewatts
    "Dog friendly, very nice neighbors, quiet, walking distance to beach & many shops, wish the sidewalks were lit at night though"
    1
    Flag
The data relating to real estate for sale or lease on this web site comes in part from OneKey® MLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Zillow, Inc are marked with the OneKey® MLS logo or an abbreviated logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright 2024 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.
The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed.