LOCATION
City, neighborhood, ZIP
  •   Shelter Island, NY
REFINE SEARCH
Set price, beds, baths, etc.


 to 


 





 to 


 to 




 to 

Sort by  
Choose an option below
$725,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
6 photos

REDUCED by $70,000 (8.8%) on Aug 21…

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ba  /  3,200 sqft  /  $227/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Brown Harris Stevens Sag Ha…

Source: bhshamptons.com bhshamptons.com

Broker: Brown Harris Stevens Sag Ha…

Agent: Peter Mccracken, Vp

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1992

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This lovely four bedroom three bath home with attached garage and pool is privately located on a quiet cul de sac. Large property and…

 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on Aug 21…

OPEN ,

Lot/Land

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Gina Surerus, SVP

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
READY TO BUILD ACREBeautiful treed, rolling acre. Plans available. Well located between town and beach.

$3,750,000
 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on Aug 21…

OPEN ,

5 br  /  4½ ba  /  2,710 sqft  /  $1,384/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Penelope Moore, Svp

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
GLORIOUS SHELTER ISLAND WATERFRONT FARMHOUSE WITH POOL, COTTAGENestled snugly behind tall privet hedges, this classic 1888 shingle…

$1,595,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
5 photos

by () on Aug 21…

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3½ ba  /  3,000 sqft  /  $532/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

1townandcountry.com

Email Gioia Dipaolo or call (631) 593-4998 to get more info

Source: 1townandcountry.com 1townandcountry.com

Broker: 1townandcountry.com

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Ward's Point - among Shelter Island's most private neighborhoods: Newly built 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath home in beautiful Shorewood Farms…

 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on Aug 21…

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ba  /  3,200 sqft  /  $227/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Peter Mccracken, Vp

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
CLASSIC COUNTRY FARM HOUSEThis lovely four bedroom three bath home with attached garage and pool is privately located on a quiet cul…

 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

REDUCED by $50,000 (14.3%) on May 12…

OPEN ,

Lot/Land

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Peter Mccracken, Vp

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
WOODED ACREAGE ON SHELTER ISLANDIn the heart of Shelter Island and once used for farming lima beans, this acreage is scattered with…

$1,950,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
8 photos

REDUCED by $650,000 (25%) on Apr 30…

OPEN ,

6 br  /  6 full, 2 partial ba   /  6,000 sqft  /  $325/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Brown Harris Stevens Bridge…

Source: bhshamptons.com bhshamptons.com

Broker: Brown Harris Stevens Bridge…

Agent: Christopher Burnside

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 2009

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Premiere example of today's best modern design elements. The newly constructed modern residence, designed by the acclaimed Morris Sato…

$3,500,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
5 photos

by () on Apr 30…

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3½ ba  /  2,362 sqft  /  $1,482/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

1townandcountry.com

Source: 1townandcountry.com 1townandcountry.com

Broker: 1townandcountry.com

Agent: John Healey

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Breathtaking views of Gardiner's Bay. Spacious post and beam home with an amazing double-sided fieldstone fireplace and full wrap-around…

 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on Apr 30…

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba  /  1,629 sqft  /  $399/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Gina Surerus, SVP

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
BRIGHT, SUNNY RANCH WITH POOL ON HALF ACRE PLUSInviting 3 bedroom, 2 bath home features an open floor plan with living room, fireplace,…

 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

REDUCED by $50,000 (14.3%) on May 13…

OPEN ,

Lot/Land

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Peter Mccracken, Vp

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
WOODED ACRE READY FOR BUILDINGIn the heart of Shelter Island and once used for farming lima beans, this acreage is scattered with clusters…

$2,245,000
 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

by () on May 13…

OPEN ,

5 br  /  4 ba  /  3,472 sqft  /  $647/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Penelope Moore, Svp

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
ST BART'S STYLE WITH SANDY BEACH ON SHELTER ISLANDSip rhum vanille on your own sandy beach or entertain a throng of friends at this…

 Shelter Is, Shelter Island NY
photos

REDUCED by $50,000 (14.3%) on May 13…

OPEN ,

Lot/Land

(11964)

The Corcoran Group

Source: corcoran.com corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Peter Mccracken, Vp

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
BUILABLE ACRE NEAR BEACH, GOLF. TENNISIn the heart of Shelter Island and once used for farming lima beans, this acreage is scattered…

$2,600,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
8 photos

by () on May 13…

OPEN ,

6 br  /  3 full, 1 partial ba   /  3,928 sqft  /  $662/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Brown Harris Stevens Sag Ha…

Source: bhshamptons.com bhshamptons.com

Broker: Brown Harris Stevens Sag Ha…

Agent: Amadeus Ehrhardt

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1883

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This magnificent Victorian residence c.1883 presides on three quarters of an acre with 108 feet of water frontage westerly facing views…

$995,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
8 photos

by () on May 13…

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ba  /  2,196 sqft  /  $453/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Brown Harris Stevens Bridge…

Source: bhshamptons.com bhshamptons.com

Broker: Brown Harris Stevens Bridge…

Agent: Tony Cerio

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1963

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Immaculate, lightfilled fourbedroom, three bath residence on a beautifully landscaped 1.56acre property with a circular driveway, outdoor…

$18,900,000
64 Burns Road, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

by () on May 13…

OPEN ,

12 br  /  12 ba  /  12,000 sqft  /  $1,575/sqft

Single-Family Home

(11964)

Sotheby's International Rea…

Source: sothebyshomes.com sothebyshomes.com

Broker: Sotheby's International Rea…

Agent: Ed Petrie

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1900

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
An extraordinary offering, this singular 24.81 +/- acre waterfront property provides an unprecedented 1,500 feet +/- of pristine beach…

 No sold properties matched your search

Tip: Try to expand your search area or adjust some of the filters.
Sorry -- An error occurred. Please try again.
Contact local agents

Connect with local Real Estate Professionals who can help you with your search.
 
Worried about spam? See our privacy policy.
(516) 612-8779
 
2
(516) 284-8993
(631) 593-4998
(631) 406-4382
 
5
Want to be listed here? Learn more
Copyright © 2012 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |  
Have a question? Visit our Help Center to find the answer

Updating results...
[x]
,
Showing address and nearby
homes for sale