Refine Search Start over


Shelter Island, NY
More neighborhood options

Custom price range



Custom beds/baths range



Info


Select multiple property types

Custom sqft range

More search options


 to 




 to 

 Expand Map
 
$1,895,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
16 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  4,250 sqft  /  $446/sqft

Single-Family Home

prudentialelliman.com

Source: prudentialelliman.com

Broker: Dorothy Herman

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 2007

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
So much more for your money on Shelter Island, this beautiful new 4 bedroom 4,250 sf home is located on one acre on a quiet street…

$2,750,000
6 Conrad Road, Shelter Island NY
12 photos

NEW CONSTRUCTION

by () on

OPEN ,

5 br  /  5 ½ ba

Single-Family Home

prudentialelliman.com

Source: prudentialelliman.com

Broker: Prudential Douglas Elliman…

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: New construction

Year Built: 2004

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Attention To Detail And Quality Craftsmanship In This Beautiful Traditional Set On .75 Acres.Gracious Entertaining.

$1,595,000
23 Osprey Road, Shelter Island NY
12 photos

REDUCED by $200,000 (11.1%) on Nov 7, 2009

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  3,000 sqft  /  $532/sqft

Single-Family Home

corcoran.com

Source: corcoran.com

Broker: The Corcoran Group

Agent: Gioia Dipaolo

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
BEACH COMMUNITY TRADITIONALpGracious new 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath home in beautiful Shorewood area of Shelter Island. Lovely design features…

$645,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
12 photos

NEW CONSTRUCTION

by () on

OPEN Saturday Dec 5th, 11am to 1pm

3 br  /  2 ba

Single-Family Home

danielgale.com

Source: danielgale.com

Broker: Daniel Gale Associates Inc

Agent: McCarthy, Linda L

Listing Type: New construction

Year Built: 1976

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Open House Times:
Saturday Dec 5th, 11am to 1pm

Description:
This Is A Beautiful Single Family Ranch, Which Has Everything You Need. In Addition To The Basics, It Has A Sunny Deck For Entertaining…

$799,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

REDUCED by $76,000 (8.7%) on Sep 26, 2009

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba  /  1,700 sqft  /  $470/sqft

Single-Family Home

vlshomes.com

Source: vlshomes.com

Agent: Janalyn Messer

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1985

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Owner Motivated. First time on the market and in move in condition. Spacious 3BR, 2BA Ranch with large back overlooking…

$875,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

REDUCED by $50,000 (5.4%) on Sep 26, 2009

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ½ ba  /  2,208 sqft  /  $396/sqft

Single-Family Home

vlshomes.com

Source: vlshomes.com

Agent: Georgiana B. Ketcham

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1993

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND SECLUDED RURAL TRADITIONAL- 1.5 acres end of cul de sac, back yard borders open space preserve. 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths,…

$899,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

REDUCED by $26,000 (2.8%) on Sep 22, 2009

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ½ ba  /  2,382 sqft  /  $377/sqft

Single-Family Home

vlshomes.com

Source: vlshomes.com

Agent: Georgiana B. Ketcham

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
SHELTER ISLAND GREATFIELDS- A house for the ages- from the late 1770's to the 21st century, this beautiful, very liveable home…

$1,795,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
2 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  3,000 sqft  /  $598/sqft

Single-Family Home

prudentialelliman.com

Source: prudentialelliman.com

Broker: Dorothy Herman

Agent: Gioia DiPaolo

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 2006

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Located in the desirable Shorewood area (which offers community tennis and private beach access for resident's only) this new…

$19,900,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
8 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

12 br  /  12 ba  /  12,000 sqft  /  $1,658/sqft

Single-Family Home

bhshamptons.com

Source: bhshamptons.com

Broker: Brown Harris Stevens Bridge…

Agent: Christopher Burnside

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1900

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
An extraordinary offering, this singular 24.81acre waterfront property provides an unprecedented 1,500' of pristine beach frontage…

$3,400,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
8 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

6 br  /  4 ½ ba  /  3,157 sqft  /  $1,077/sqft

Single-Family Home

bhshamptons.com

Source: bhshamptons.com

Broker: Brown Harris Stevens Sag Ha…

Agent: Caroline Sarraf

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 1860

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This magnificent Italianate Victorian residence c.1860 presides over 2.94acres of lushly landscaped property on scenic Menantic Creek…

$1,499,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

5 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  5,284 sqft  /  $284/sqft

Single-Family Home

1townandcountry.com

Source: 1townandcountry.com

Broker: Town and Country Real Estate

Agent: Nicholas J. Planamento

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
All the grandure of a High Victorian, including a center hall staircase worthy of a movie set, high ceilings, handcrafted ornomentation…

$760,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

3 br  /  1 ½ ba  /  1,496 sqft  /  $508/sqft

Single-Family Home

1townandcountry.com

Source: 1townandcountry.com

Broker: Town and Country Real Estate

Agent: Jeanmarie Bay

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Just 1/10 of a mile to a beautiful Peconic Bay Beach, thie meticulously maintained home offers an open kitchen, dining, and living…

$1,895,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ½ ba  /  4,250 sqft  /  $446/sqft

Single-Family Home

1townandcountry.com

Source: 1townandcountry.com

Broker: Town and Country Real Estate

Agent: Alicia Ward

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
Enjoy all the luxury of quality new construction: Builder's newly constructed home on 1 beautiful Shelter Island acre with 4 bedrooms,…

$995,000
Address Not Disclosed, Shelter Island NY
3 photos

JUST ADDED

by () on

OPEN ,

4 br  /  3 ba  /  2,196 sqft  /  $453/sqft

Single-Family Home

1townandcountry.com

Source: 1townandcountry.com

Broker: Town and Country Real Estate

Agent: Jeanmarie Bay

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built:

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This newly renovated, 4 bedroom, 3 bath home is great for a family gathering and entertaining friends. New heating and Air Conditioning…

30 Brander Parkway, Shelter Island NY
28 photos

by () on

OPEN ,

3 br  /  2 ba  /  1,933 sqft  /  $414/sqft

Single-Family Home

Prudential Douglas Elliman…

Source: Prudential Douglas Elliman…

Agent: Glen Hagen, LSA, e-PRO

Listing Type: Resale

Year Built: 2000

Neighborhood:

ZIP: 11964

Description:
This Custom, All Vinyl, Maintenance-Free Home, Built Very Recently (2000) in Silver Beach on a Spacious 3/4 Acre Property is Awaiting…

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 13
0 properties matched your search.
Try these search tips:
  • Broaden your search by expanding your search criteria.
  • Expand your search area to include more areas.
  • Set up an email alert to get notified when listings come on the market.
Try a new search Sign up for listing alerts
Local Spotlight
Copyright © 2009 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Help us improve our service—send us feedback





Updating results...
[x]
,
Showing address and nearby
homes for sale